The Cleveland Browns’ approach to the 2025 NFL Draft was a fascinating mix of strategy and pragmatism, as they set out to address immediate needs while also keeping an eye on the future. With a roster that required reinforcements across multiple positions, from the offensive and defensive lines to finding dynamic playmakers, the team navigated the draft with a clear vision in mind.
Let’s dive into each selection, highlighting how they fit into the overarching plan that the Browns have established, and provide an overall grade at the finish.
Mason Graham, DT, Michigan – A
The Browns made a strong first impression with their pick of Mason Graham, a steady and highly skilled defensive tackle. Graham’s film showcases a player who excels at dominating the line of scrimmage. His ability to leverage his strength, combined with quick hands and relentless hustle, makes him an ideal addition alongside Myles Garrett and the rest of a robust defensive front.
Cleveland not only landed a promising prospect in Graham but also secured additional picks by trading down, including a first-round selection for 2026. This choice is a home run, affirming that the Browns are building a formidable defense.
Carson Schwesinger, LB, UCLA – B
Continuing to bolster their defense, the Browns selected Carson Schwesinger, a high-energy linebacker from UCLA. Known for his ability to instinctively react to plays, even as he navigates the complexities of NFL offenses, Schwesinger’s determination stands out.
While he may face challenges in his early days, particularly in diagnosis and coverage, his knack for making plays and his special teams potential provide immediate value. He’s the kind of player who brings intensity to the field, fitting well into the Browns’ aggressive defensive approach.
Quinshon Judkins, RB, Ohio State – B-
The selection of Quinshon Judkins added depth to the backfield, but it raised a few eyebrows as running back wasn’t a critical position for Cleveland. Judkins is known for his toughness and ability to gain tough yards, traits that will surely benefit the team.
However, he lacks the explosiveness and dynamic playmaking capabilities that can change a game, which might leave some fans wanting more from this pick. While he brings a solid option in short-yardage situations, there were arguably more impactful choices available at this stage.
Harold Fannin Jr., TE, Bowling Green – A
Perhaps one of the gems of the draft, Harold Fannin Jr. is a tight end with an exciting skill set that promises to keep defenses guessing. His versatility allows him to thrive in various roles, whether lined up inline or positioned as a flexible weapon in the slot.
Given the Browns’ reliance on their tight ends in a play-action-heavy offense, this selection could yield significant dividends down the line. With Fannin’s potential, the team has found a dynamic piece that could really open up their offensive playbook.
Dillon Gabriel, QB, Oregon – D+
With the selection of Dillon Gabriel, the Browns ventured into the quarterback market, albeit with questions surrounding the pick. While Gabriel has shown competence at Oregon, concerns over his arm strength and size loom large, particularly in a league where durability is crucial.
In a quarterback room that already features Joe Flacco, the selection of Gabriel feels more like a gamble than a calculated move to find a long-term solution. It’s a pick that raises eyebrows more than it reassures, as Cleveland grapples with securing a reliable backup plan.
Dylan Sampson, RB, Tennessee – B+
Adding Dylan Sampson to the roster injects a much-needed spark into the Browns’ backfield. His quickness and ability to break away from defenders make him a potential game-changer. Although he’s not the most physically imposing back, Sampson’s ability to catch passes out of the backfield provides valuable versatility for the offense.
As a change-of-pace option, Sampson could carve out a niche while providing exciting playmaking ability whenever he’s on the field.
Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado – A-
One of the most promising picks from this draft class has to be Shedeur Sanders. Although the Browns have established veterans on the roster, Sanders brings an impressive skill set that showcases his starting potential. His poise, touch, and ability to make plays with his legs set him apart as a quarterback who could thrive at the next level.
Even if he doesn’t see immediate playing time, his long-term upside makes this selection a major win for Cleveland. He’s the type of player who could define this draft down the line if he realizes his potential.
Final Thoughts – Overall Grade: B+
In summary, the Browns’ 2025 draft class brings a blend of solid selections and some head-scratchers, reflecting their aim for both immediate impact and future potential. With standout picks like Mason Graham and Harold Fannin Jr. set to become integral parts of the squad, and the tantalizing possibilities offered by Shedeur Sanders, there’s plenty for fans in Cleveland to be excited about.
However, the presence of a couple questionable picks—including the choice to bring in Dillon Gabriel—keeps the overall grade from being an A+. Still, this draft illustrates a commitment to building a well-rounded team, and if the players develop as hoped, the Browns could be turning a corner in their quest for sustained competitiveness.
