The Indianapolis Colts face a pivotal offseason, one that could redefine their offensive future. Michael Pittman Jr., their top wide receiver, has been a key piece of their attack, but trading him might be the unexpected move that sets the team up for long-term success.
At first glance, moving on from Pittman seems counterintuitive—why trade your best wide receiver when you’re still developing Anthony Richardson? But a deeper look at the Colts’ roster and financial situation makes the case compelling. Pittman is due for a big payday, and with three talented receivers—Josh Downs, Alec Pierce, and Adonai Mitchell—on rookie deals, Indianapolis has the flexibility to pivot.
Why Trading Pittman Makes Sense
Chris Ballard, the Colts’ general manager, has made it clear: competition at quarterback is coming. That could mean adding a veteran QB to push Richardson, or even an aggressive move in the draft. Either way, those resources need to come from somewhere. Trading Pittman could help free up $13 million in cap space, giving the Colts the ability to go after key free agents or lock in crucial long-term extensions.
Then there’s the style of play. Pittman is a big, physical target, but the Colts’ offense under Shane Steichen needs more explosiveness. Downs and Mitchell bring that big-play ability, and if Indianapolis can flip Pittman for premium draft capital, they could reinforce the offensive line or defense without losing too much firepower.
Where Could Pittman Land?
Several teams could use a big-bodied, possession receiver like Pittman:
- Buffalo Bills – Pittman would be the perfect long-term WR1 for Josh Allen.
- New England Patriots – They need a legitimate top wideout, and Pittman could be the reliable target their young QB desperately needs.
- Chicago Bears – If they’re all in on Caleb Williams, adding Pittman alongside DJ Moore would instantly elevate their passing game.
Final Thoughts
Trading Pittman would be a bold but strategic move for Indianapolis. The Colts aren’t in full rebuild mode, but they are transitioning—and allocating resources wisely is key. With young receivers ready to step up, flipping Pittman for draft capital or a high-impact player could be exactly what this team needs to take the next step.
