The New York Giants are at a critical juncture as they gear up for the 2025 season. After a tumultuous past few years, the decision to retain head coach Brian Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen has raised eyebrows, but now, the pressure is mounting for Schoen. If the Giants don’t find a definitive direction at quarterback or secure a winning record this season, it may spell the end of his tenure.
The Case for Keeping Joe Schoen
Schoen’s 2024 draft class is showing promise, with players like Malik Nabers, Tyrone Tracy, and Theo Johnson emerging as potential starters. This is significant because it represents a fresh start for the Giants after parting ways with Daniel Jones. If Schoen can bring in a new quarterback who shows immediate potential in Year One, he might just buy himself some time. The hope is that with the right signal-caller, the Giants can regain their competitive edge in the NFC.
The Case for Firing Joe Schoen
However, the clock is ticking. While the Giants had a solid playoff run in the inaugural season post-Dave Gettleman’s reign, the reality since then has been stark: a dismal 9-25 record over the last two seasons, with declining performance year after year. Although the Giants have finally moved away from Daniel Jones, the urgency to solidify the quarterback position is critical.
It’s worth noting the prevailing sentiment at the NFL Combine: some believe the Giants don’t necessarily need to post a winning record this season as long as they demonstrate progress from last year’s three-win debacle. However, that’s a viewpoint that could be seen as too lenient. The time to start winning is now.
Right now, the Giants find themselves in a precarious situation with Tommy DeVito as their starting QB, while both Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston have been brought in for visits. The expectation might be for them to sign Winston and draft Jaxson Dart in the second round. Even with that potential move, if the Giants fail to secure more than six victories this season, it might be time to part ways with Schoen.
In the high-stakes environment of the NFL, every season counts. While a long-term vision can be appealing, the Giants possess enough talent on their roster to be a playoff contender. The missing piece? A stable, effective quarterback situation. It’s time for Schoen to make the moves that could finally elevate this franchise back to prominence.
