Giants And 49’ers Will Exchange First Round Picks In NFL Draft

Dec 29, 2024; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; New York Giants head coach Brian Daboll looks on during the first half against the Indianapolis Colts at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

The New York Giants are shaking things up in their quarterback room, having recently added former Pro Bowler Russell Wilson alongside Jameis Winston. This bold move suggests that the Giants are setting their sights on a long-term plan for a franchise quarterback, directing their focus toward the promising 2026 draft class rather than forcing a selection this year.

Opting to stall their search for a quarterback until 2026 seems like a savvy strategy for the Giants. That class boasts a wealth of talent, which could provide a stronger foundation for the franchise to build upon. This approach changes the dynamics around their third overall pick in the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft—rather than using it for a quarterback, they have the flexibility to explore other avenues.

Recent buzz indicates the San Francisco 49ers are eyeing that third overall pick, presenting a potential trade scenario that could benefit both teams.

Proposed Trade:

  • New York Giants Receive:
  • 2025 First Round Pick (11th Overall)
  • 2025 Third Round Pick
  • 2025 Fourth Round Pick
  • 2026 Second Round Pick
  • San Francisco 49ers Receive:
  • 2025 First Round Pick (3rd Overall)

Why This Trade Makes Sense for the Giants

Moving back in the draft allows the Giants to stockpile valuable draft capital. This strategy not only fills crucial needs across their roster but also secures assets that can help them bolster their team ahead of their inevitable quarterback selection in 2026. With the ability to draft at 11th overall, they can still snag some impressive talent, including prospects like Will Campbell, Jahdae Barron, Will Johnson, Kenneth Grant, Luther Burden, or Matthew Golden. The options are plenty, ensuring a brighter future for the Giants’ offense as they work toward setting up their eventual quarterback for success.

The 49ers’ Motivation to Trade Up

For the 49ers, the decision to trade up could be pivotal as their current quarterback, Brock Purdy, enters a critical contract year. They face a decision regarding his future in a landscape that could see them transitioning to a new face at the position. Much like their aggressive move in the 2021 draft to snag Trey Lance, the chance to secure Shedeur Sanders at third overall could provide a tantalizing opportunity for head coach Kyle Shanahan. Sanders’ playstyle aligns with Shanahan’s vision for the offense, making this a decision that could define the 49ers’ trajectory toward youth and dynamism on that side of the ball.

As the draft draws nearer, all eyes will be on the Giants and 49ers, as this trade scenario unfolds. Each team has its own priorities, but finding common ground could yield significant returns for both franchises. The chess match that is the NFL draft continues, and it promises to be an exciting ride as we head toward 2025!