As the Indianapolis Colts prepare for an intriguing showdown between Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones for the starting quarterback role, one critical area of concern stands out: the tight end position. Currently, the depth chart in that spot leaves a bit to be desired, and it’s crucial that the offense has the right personnel in place to ensure this competition is as fair as possible.
While the prospect of drafting a rookie tight end like Tyler Warren, Mason Taylor, Colston Loveland, or Harold Fannin exists, relying solely on a first-year player to step in right away might not be the wisest move for a team that’s looking to bolster its offense immediately. Instead, a trade for a seasoned tight end could significantly enhance the Colts’ chances this season.
One name that has cropped up in offseason discussions is Dallas Goedert from the Philadelphia Eagles. With whispers of a potential trade swirling around him, the Colts should seriously consider seizing this opportunity. At 30 years old, Goedert may not be a long-term solution, but he brings invaluable experience and skill to the table, having just celebrated a Super Bowl victory. Last season, he logged 711 receiving yards, averaged 12.1 yards per catch, and scored three touchdowns. Those numbers reflect a player who’s still operating at a high level, showing no signs of the decline that might be expected as he reaches his thirties.
A significant advantage in pursuing Goedert is the existing relationship he has with Colts head coach Shane Steichen. During Steichen’s tenure as the Eagles’ offensive coordinator from 2021 to 2022, Goedert thrived, producing the best numbers of his career—922 yards and four touchdowns in 2021, followed by 843 yards and another four touchdowns in 2022. With this familiarity, Steichen could easily adapt the offense to get the most out of Goedert once again, easing his transition into the Colts’ system.
For Richardson or Jones, both of whom have faced challenges with accuracy in their respective careers, having a reliable target like Goedert—who boasts a career reception rate of 76.7%—could prove invaluable in high-pressure situations. This is especially critical as both quarterbacks look to establish their rhythm early on.
From a logistical standpoint, the Colts would likely only need to part with a fifth-round pick to make this trade happen. This allows them to focus on other pressing needs during the upcoming NFL Draft while enabling the Eagles to continue building their depth with additional picks. This potential move represents a win-win situation for both clubs: the Colts would solidify their roster while the Eagles could further strategize for future success.
In short, a trade for Dallas Goedert could be just what the Colts need to create a more competitive atmosphere as they decide who will lead their offense moving forward.
