The Cleveland Browns find themselves facing a crucial decision as the 2025 offseason looms: how to tackle their quarterback predicament. With the current situation, exploring young talents like Shedeur Sanders or Cam Ward in the draft might mean rolling the dice on uncertain potential. Instead, a more reliable short-term solution could shine in the form of a trade with the Seattle Seahawks for veteran quarterback Geno Smith.
Deshaun Watson, who was once the centerpiece of a major trade, has struggled to meet the high expectations set for him in Cleveland. Over his tenure, Watson’s performance has been underwhelming, with just 3,365 passing yards, 19 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. His pocket presence has faltered, leading to 70 sacks, and his decision-making on the field has been shaky, often resulting in turnovers or stalling the offense. Compounding these issues is an Achilles injury that casts a shadow over his availability for the 2024 season, making it imperative for the Browns to seek alternatives.
Head coach Kevin Stefanski, under pressure after a tough 2024 season, seems unlikely to gamble on a developmental quarterback this year, especially with the draft pool lacking a clear standout option. The Browns need stability to navigate the upcoming season, and Geno Smith could provide just that. With his experience, Smith represents an ideal bridge quarterback who can offer the steady hand Cleveland needs right now.
From the Seahawks’ perspective, the timing appears favorable to embrace a younger quarterback in the draft. Coach Mike Macdonald is better positioned to take such a risk, given Seattle’s promising pool of young talent in players like DK Metcalf, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, and Kenneth Walker. These rising stars create a nurturing environment for a rookie quarterback to develop. While Geno Smith has been solid for Seattle, it seems they’ve hit their ceiling with him at the helm, signaling that change might be on the horizon.
Smith’s track record showcases his potential value to the Browns. Last season, he completed an impressive 70.4% of his passes, amassing 4,320 yards and 21 touchdowns. Despite 15 interceptions, his leadership helped guide the Seahawks to a winning record. For Cleveland, Smith’s consistent play could be the answer to their 2025 season, bringing the stability and reliability they urgently need at the quarterback position.
