Tetairoa McMillan, a former Arizona Wildcats star and top NFL draft prospect, has found himself at the center of controversy after a resurfaced podcast clip revealed that he doesn’t like to watch or study football.
McMillan’s alarming admission, which quickly went viral, has ignited a debate among fans and analysts, with many questioning whether a serious NFL hopeful can succeed without immersing himself in the game beyond practice.
Many critics argue that McMillan’s remarks suggest a lack of dedication, particularly for a player striving to make it at the professional level.
Among those raising concerns is Hall of Famer Shannon Sharpe, who did not hold back his criticism during an episode of his Nightcap podcast.
Sharpe was blunt in his reaction to McMillan’s statement, comparing the young receiver to JaMarcus Russell, the former No. 1 overall pick who infamously failed to live up to expectations in the NFL.
“Everything that’s thought doesn’t need to be said out loud. Some things you just keep to yourself. I want you to tell me what you think them 32 NFL teams thinking. That’s what I don’t get. I don’t get because you know how teams feel… Why would you ever say this publicly when you’re about to get [drafted]?” Sharpe said.
Sharpe also brought up Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray, who was once at the center of a controversy over a contract clause requiring him to limit distractions, such as playing video games, to ensure he dedicated enough time to film study.
Despite the backlash, some fans have come to McMillan’s defense, arguing that his comments may not accurately reflect his current mindset.
Josh Sanchez of The Big Lead pointed out that the podcast clip in question was recorded in 2023, suggesting McMillan may have since adjusted his approach after receiving input from coaches and mentors.
Sanchez also noted that wide receivers, unlike quarterbacks, often rely more on reviewing plays in team meetings rather than watching full games independently. He argued that McMillan’s approach could be a way to maintain balance and avoid burnout rather than an outright lack of commitment.
However, it’s hard to downplay just how concerning McMillan’s comments are. As Sharpe pointed out, NFL teams are searching for players who are “all-in” in every single aspect of football – both on and off the field.
Needless to say, Sharpe wasn’t the only former player to call out McMillan.
His co-host, Chad “Ochocinco” Johnson, a former Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver known for his strong opinions, also weighed in during Nightcap, expressing disbelief over McMillan’s admission.
With the NFL Draft approaching, McMillan’s comments could influence how teams perceive him. Whether his approach is seen as a red flag or simply a different method of preparation remains to be seen.
What are your thoughts on McMillan’s controversial comments???
