NFL legend and ESPN analyst Randy Moss is currently crafting his list of the top five quarterbacks in the league, and there’s a notable debate brewing around whether Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert should be included.
Moss shared his nearly complete list on X, featuring standout names like Patrick Mahomes from the Kansas City Chiefs, Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills, Lamar Jackson representing the Baltimore Ravens, and Joe Burrow of the Cincinnati Bengals. He posed a question that many fans might be pondering: “Who’s the 5th?”
While Herbert’s inclusion on such a prestigious list isn’t a foregone conclusion, it certainly seems like he deserves at least a seat at the table. Since breaking into the league in 2020, Herbert has amassed an impressive 21,093 passing yards—second only to Mahomes and Allen during that stretch. He also ranks fifth in passing touchdowns with 137 and stands sixth in wins, totaling 41.
Last season might have left critics wondering about Herbert’s performance, as it could be labeled a statistical down year. However, it also showcased his resilience under tough circumstances. The Chargers’ offensive line struggled significantly, tying for the sixth-most sacks allowed, yet Herbert maintained a remarkable interception rate of just 0.6%, leading the NFL in that category. Throwing only three interceptions throughout the season underscores his accuracy and decision-making under pressure.
Adding to Herbert’s narrative is the tumultuous state of his receiving corps, which faced its fair share of inconsistencies. Despite the challenges, Herbert’s ability to remain focused and productive in an adverse environment speaks volumes about his potential. With a more cohesive and reliable supporting cast, the possibilities are endless for what he can achieve on the field.
However, the biggest hurdle for Herbert is the absence of playoff success. The Chargers have only reached the postseason twice since he made his debut, and unfortunately, they have yet to secure a playoff win with him leading the charge. For Herbert to solidify his status among the top five quarterbacks in the league, he will need to elevate his game further—ideally surpassing that 4,000-yard mark again, protecting the football with diligence, and guiding the Chargers on a formidable playoff run.
The spotlight is on Herbert not just to perform, but to transform potential into tangible success. As fans watch closely this upcoming season, the conversation around his place among the elite quarterbacks in the league will only intensify.
