In Thursday’s edition of “First Call,” we dive into the significant buzz surrounding the Pittsburgh Steelers’ decision to trade George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys, a move that has many wondering about the future direction of the team.
Former Steelers player Ryan Clark didn’t hold back on ESPN’s “Get Up” when discussing the trade. He suggested that the franchise might be signaling a shift toward rebuilding, asserting, “It sounds like they’re tanking. I know they are, because they’ve made other moves. When you look at this roster, this roster can’t compete to have a winning season. This roster can’t compete to be a playoff team. This roster can’t compete to be an AFC champion.” If the Steelers miss the playoffs this season, it would mark the first time they’ve done so since 2003, a fact that only intensifies the scrutiny they’re facing.
Clark elaborated, emphasizing the unsettling nature of the current roster dynamics and the organization’s management. “It’s not only about what the roster looks like; it’s the way they’re moving and maneuvering around building this roster,” he said. Despite his concerns, he expressed his confidence in general manager Omar Khan and head coach Mike Tomlin, though he noted, “This isn’t a team I’d put any money on.”
Despite Clark’s strong stance, some might argue that the Steelers are simply grappling with the repercussions of mismanagement over the years. The timing of the trade—accepting a draft pick for 2026 rather than making a push for immediate talent—suggests a shift in strategy. It’s a notable move for a franchise that has historically prided itself on competitiveness.
Adding to the narrative of potential tanking, a historical tidbit has surfaced: according to Steelers Depot, this may mark the first time in the club’s 92-year history—excluding merger years with the Cardinals and Eagles—that the Steelers will begin a season without the previous year’s leading passer, rusher, and receiver. The departures of Russell Wilson, Najee Harris, and of course, Pickens, leave a noticeable vacuum on the roster.
The buzz around the league, especially from CBS Sports’ Jonathan Jones, paints a picture of inevitability regarding Pickens’ exit. Jones noted the clear signals emanating from the Steelers organization, particularly following the recent DK Metcalf trade. “Not a surprise at all that George Pickens is no longer going to be a Pittsburgh Steeler,” Jones remarked.
On the draft front, the Steelers are positioning themselves with a promising haul, projected to have five picks in the first two days of the NFL Draft. This includes their own first-round draft selection, a second-round pick, and three third-rounders, bolstered by a compensatory pick expected from Justin Fields’ departure to New York.
In other news, former Steelers center Maurkice Pouncey was honored with induction into the University of Florida Athletics Hall of Fame. Pouncey, drafted by the Steelers in 2010, earned accolades during his collegiate career, including the Rimington Trophy for the nation’s top center. His time at Florida was highlighted by being part of the 2008 National Championship team and establishing himself as a key player before going on to a successful NFL career.
Lastly, former Pitt star and Rams legend Aaron Donald has been navigating some serious personal challenges. He recently obtained a five-year restraining order against a woman who allegedly has been stalking him and his family. This legal victory for Donald comes after years of distress, including threats to his young son and bizarre claims regarding a supposed marriage. A troubling ordeal that underscores the complexities athletes can face off the field.
As the NFL landscape evolves, the Steelers face critical decisions that will shape their roster and identity well into the future. The echoes of past seasons linger as fans look for clarity amidst what feels like a pivotal moment in franchise history.
