Did Dalton Kincaid Cost Josh Allen His Best Shot At A Super Bowl?

The Buffalo Bills’ 2024 season came to a bitter end in a familiar and heartbreaking fashion as they fell to the Kansas City Chiefs, 32-29 in the AFC Championship Game.

In a game marked by twists and turns, a pivotal drop by star tight end Dalton Kincaid on the Bills’ final drive left fans wondering what might have been.

With just two minutes left in the game and facing a critical 4th-and-5, quarterback Josh Allen launched a desperation pass downfield in a bid to keep Buffalo’s season alive.

It was actually a phenomenal play by Allen – and Kincaid managed to position himself to make the catch, but the ball slipped through his hands in heartbreaking fashion.

The incomplete pass gave the Chiefs possession, allowing them to ultimately run out the clock and punch their ticket to the Super Bowl.

After the game, Kincaid was candid about the nightmare moment.

“I mean, it’s football. Josh made a hell of an attempt just to get the ball up there, and it just sucks a lot,” Kincaid said. “Obviously, just knowing we don’t get to play another game as this team and we don’t make it on to that next step, it just hurts a lot.”

Had Kincaid caught the ball, the Bills would have continued their drive and would have been in position for a game-tying field goal at the very least.

The loss is yet another chapter in a frustrating playoff saga for the Bills, who have repeatedly seen their postseason dreams dashed by Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs.

Each year, optimism builds as Buffalo establishes itself as one of the league’s elite teams during the regular season. Yet, when the postseason arrives, their championship aspirations continue to unravel against Kansas City.

While Kincaid’s drop will undoubtedly be remembered as one of the defining moment of the game, the loss cannot be pinned solely on him.

The Bills had opportunities throughout the contest to seize control, but they were unable to capitalize on key plays when it mattered most.

(Let’s be honest: the officiating didn’t help either…)

As the Bills head into another offseason of soul-searching, the team – and its fans – are left to grapple with the all-too-familiar sting of falling just short.

Buffalo’s quest to reach the Super Bowl endures, but the lingering memory of how close they came this time will remain a painful motivator.

For now, the Chiefs move on, while the Bills are left to regroup and find answers to the questions that have haunted them for years.

At the end of the day, it’s yet another wasted year off Allen’s career…

What are your thoughts on Kincaid’s drop? … Did he (indirectly) cost Allen his best chance at winning a Super Bowl???