Titans Trade #1 Pick for Vikings QB JJ McCarthy?

The Tennessee Titans have struck a goldmine with the #1 Overall Pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. This coveted position opens up a world of possibilities. Should they draft Cam Ward, potentially their quarterback of the future? Or opt for Travis Hunter, possibly the best player available? Alternatively, they might leverage this prime spot in a trade to secure a quarterback who fits their long-term vision.

2025 Tennessee Titans Three-Round Mock Draft

Evaluating Cam Ward’s Potential

There’s buzz around Cam Ward as a top choice for the Titans. But when we consider Titans Head Coach Brian Callahan’s track record, the fit seems questionable. Callahan’s career is a highlight reel of collaborations with quarterbacks known for their cerebral command of the game. Working with the likes of Peyton Manning, Matthew Stafford, and Joe Burrow, it’s clear he values elite processors in the pocket—a skill set that doesn’t define Ward’s play style.

Trading the #1 Pick

There’s serious intrigue in trading the top pick. Here’s a proposed scenario:

  • Titans Receive: Quarterback JJ McCarthy, 1st Round Pick in 2025, 1st Round Pick in 2026, 2nd Round Pick in 2026
  • Vikings Receive: #1 Overall Pick in 2025 NFL Draft

To put this into perspective, just look at past trades involving the #1 pick. The 2023 Chicago Bears snagged wide receiver DJ Moore plus two first-rounders and two second-rounders for their top pick. Back in 2016, the Titans themselves secured a treasure trove of picks, totaling two firsts, two seconds, and a third, all for moving down to the 15th spot.

This trade would grant the Vikings a valuable chance at Travis Hunter, heralded as a potentially generational talent. Alternatively, they might flip the pick again, catering to a team eager to move up for a high-profile quarterback like Shedeur Sanders.

From what we’ve seen at Michigan, JJ McCarthy showcases the elite footwork and pocket presence that make him an attractive prospect for Callahan. His processing skills align well with what Callahan values, possibly setting up a productive partnership.

As the Titans ponder their options, the stakes couldn’t be higher. Whether anchoring their rebuild on a fresh talent or reshaping their roster through trades, it’s a pivotal moment for Tennessee’s football future.