The Texas Longhorns Are Overrated And Ranked Too High In The CFP. Here’s Why

Dec 7, 2024; Atlanta, GA, USA; Texas Longhorns quarterback Quinn Ewers (3) drops back to pass against the Georgia Bulldogs during the first half in the 2024 SEC Championship game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Dale Zanine-Imagn Images

The Texas Longhorns have clinched the 5th seed in the newly expanded 12-team College Football Playoff and are set to host Dabo Swinney’s Clemson Tigers in what promises to be a thrilling opening round. With the stakes as high as they get, it’s time to dive deep into whether the Longhorns deserve such a prestigious placement and what this matchup spells for the playoff picture.

Notre Dame’s Frustration Grows

Notre Dame fans are finding themselves in a familiar place—on edge and, frankly, frustrated. With a solid 11-1 season, the Fighting Irish faithful were confident they’d lock down that 5th seed. Yet, Texas’ fall in the SEC championship didn’t send them spiraling as expected. Instead, Notre Dame was nudged down to the 6th seed. Now, they’re facing an Indiana Hoosiers squad that’s set on making a playoff splash before potentially facing the mighty Georgia Bulldogs. Being the 5th seed would have offered a seemingly smoother path, a notion sure to keep fans restless.

Assessing Texas’ Schedule and Performance

The chatter around the Longhorns this season has been less than flattering. Critics argue that they’ve waltzed through the season without truly proving themselves against top-tier foes. The missing jewel in their crown? A victory against a significant powerhouse. Sure, there’s a win over Texas A&M, but its luster seems to be fading in public perception.

Contrast this with other top programs: Oregon stands undefeated with impressive scalps, including Ohio State and Penn State. Georgia boasts victories against Texas (twice!), Tennessee, and Clemson, plus narrow defeats to titans like Alabama. Across the nation, teams have battled and emerged with marquee wins, whereas Texas is left with some not-so-standout victories.

The Accusation of Overrating

Given Texas’ relatively soft schedule and crucial losses to Georgia, the claims of them being overrated gain traction. Critics argue they’ve been rewarded more for what could have been rather than what was achieved on the gridiron. There’s something to be said for teams like Boise State playing Oregon tougher than anyone else, or Arizona State taking down the likes of BYU, Kansas State, and Iowa State, adding weight to claims of an imbalance in playoff placements.

Texas vs. Clemson: The Battle Breakdown

On the field, Texas will enjoy the comforts of playing at home, but they’ll need more than just familiar turf to see off Cade Klubnik and a fired-up Clemson team. Klubnik’s form is a concern for any opponent, yet the Texas defense, fresh off the sting of an SEC championship loss, is expected to be razor-sharp.

Quinn Ewers, Texas’ hope in the air, must elevate his performance and steady his receivers – those Georgia game drops cannot afford a repeat. It’s about taking their game to another level, and if they do, there’s a clear path to a 31-23 victory over Clemson, setting the stage for a showdown with the Big 12 champion Arizona State.

As the Longhorns brace for the Tigers’ visit, college football fans will be watching closely, ready to see if the 5th seed lives up to its billing. This playoff debut isn’t just a game; it’s a declaration of intent.

The Texas Longhorns have clinched the 5th seed in the newly expanded 12-team College Football Playoff and are set to host Dabo Swinney’s Clemson Tigers in what promises to be a thrilling opening round. With the stakes as high as they get, it’s time to dive deep into whether the Longhorns deserve such a prestigious placement and what this matchup spells for the playoff picture.

Notre Dame’s Frustration Grows

Notre Dame fans are finding themselves in a familiar place—on edge and, frankly, frustrated. With a solid 11-1 season, the Fighting Irish faithful were confident they’d lock down that 5th seed. Yet, Texas’ fall in the SEC championship didn’t send them spiraling as expected. Instead, Notre Dame was nudged down to the 6th seed. Now, they’re facing an Indiana Hoosiers squad that’s set on making a playoff splash before potentially facing the mighty Georgia Bulldogs. Being the 5th seed would have offered a seemingly smoother path, a notion sure to keep fans restless.

Assessing Texas’ Schedule and Performance

The chatter around the Longhorns this season has been less than flattering. Critics argue that they’ve waltzed through the season without truly proving themselves against top-tier foes. The missing jewel in their crown? A victory against a significant powerhouse. Sure, there’s a win over Texas A&M, but its luster seems to be fading in public perception.

Contrast this with other top programs: Oregon stands undefeated with impressive scalps, including Ohio State and Penn State. Georgia boasts victories against Texas (twice!), Tennessee, and Clemson, plus narrow defeats to titans like Alabama. Across the nation, teams have battled and emerged with marquee wins, whereas Texas is left with some not-so-standout victories.

The Accusation of Overrating

Given Texas’ relatively soft schedule and crucial losses to Georgia, the claims of them being overrated gain traction. Critics argue they’ve been rewarded more for what could have been rather than what was achieved on the gridiron. There’s something to be said for teams like Boise State playing Oregon tougher than anyone else, or Arizona State taking down the likes of BYU, Kansas State, and Iowa State, adding weight to claims of an imbalance in playoff placements.

Texas vs. Clemson: The Battle Breakdown

On the field, Texas will enjoy the comforts of playing at home, but they’ll need more than just familiar turf to see off Cade Klubnik and a fired-up Clemson team. Klubnik’s form is a concern for any opponent, yet the Texas defense, fresh off the sting of an SEC championship loss, is expected to be razor-sharp.

Quinn Ewers, Texas’ hope in the air, must elevate his performance and steady his receivers – those Georgia game drops cannot afford a repeat. It’s about taking their game to another level, and if they do, there’s a clear path to a 31-23 victory over Clemson, setting the stage for a showdown with the Big 12 champion Arizona State.

As the Longhorns brace for the Tigers’ visit, college football fans will be watching closely, ready to see if the 5th seed lives up to its billing. This playoff debut isn’t just a game; it’s a declaration of intent.