Nick Castellanos Benched After Saying WHAT to Phillies Manager

Nick Castellanos Benched After Saying WHAT to Phillies Manager Nick Castellanos Benched After Saying WHAT to Phillies Manager
Jun 11, 2025; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Nick Castellanos (8) reacts during a replay review after hitting a triple against the Chicago Cubs in the third inning at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Ross-Imagn Images

Nick Castellanos, a fierce competitor in the Philadelphia Phillies’ lineup, found himself in unfamiliar territory recently as he was benched for the first time since September 2023. Ending his remarkable streak of 236 consecutive starts, the team opted to sideline one of their most reliable hitters. Known for his passionate approach to the game, Castellanos never shies away from speaking his mind. Recently, this trait led to his being benched after a clash involving his manager, Rob Thomson.

It all began when an “inappropriate comment” emerged from Castellanos during a game against the Marlins. Slotted out in the eighth inning for defensive changes involving Johan Rojas and Max Kepler, Castellanos apparently voiced his frustration directly to Thomson. While the specifics of the comment remain undisclosed, it was enough for the team to draw a line.

Despite the incident, Thomson was quick to acknowledge Castellanos’ passion for baseball as being at the heart of the matter. The manager expressed admiration for Castellanos’ emotions, underscoring how deeply the outfielder loves playing every inning. Yet, it was deemed necessary to bench him, in response to crossing a line with his verbal outburst.

“Nick is someone who plays with a lot of heart and emotion,” Thomson remarked. “He wants to be out there, helping the team. But there was a comment after last night’s game that I felt was inappropriate, and he’s sitting out today as a result. But we’re moving past it.”

Castellanos himself acknowledged the lapse, accepting the benching as a consequence of his actions. Statistically speaking, he’s facing a bit of a slow start this season. With a .278 batting average, seven home runs, 36 RBIs, and 76 hits, Castellanos is still working to find his stride. Meanwhile, the Phillies as a team are grappling with their own challenges, reflected by a drop in the week 11 MLB power rankings.

This situation with Castellanos serves as a reminder of the thin line between passion and impulsivity—a balance every player must navigate. As for the Phillies, they’ll hope their star outfielder finds his form soon, channeling his fervor back into performance on the field.