The NFL Draft is always a showcase of talent, and this year’s first round delivered plenty of drama, albeit with some surprising omissions. With only two quarterbacks taken in Round 1, the recent draft saw the fewest signal-callers selected since Kenny Pickett was the sole first-round choice in 2022. While the quarterback talent may have been lacking this time around, there were still some standout players who made the cut.
A noteworthy highlight was the fact that this draft featured multiple tight ends—namely Colston Loveland and Tyler Warren—being selected within the first 14 picks for the first time since 1973. Additionally, the SEC and Big Ten dominated the stage, contributing 26 of the 32 selections in the first round. This trend emphasizes the concentration of elite talent residing in these power conferences.
Although the first night was filled with excitement, several quality players were left without a name being called. The question of whether these athletes possess true Round 1 talent might be debated, but they are certainly poised to be enticing picks as teams move into Round 2 and beyond. So, who were the biggest surprises that didn’t hear their names on Day 1? Let’s take a look at five players who definitely warrant some attention.
Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado
Shedeur Sanders came into the draft with high expectations, thanks in large part to the endorsement of his father, Deion Sanders—the head coach at Colorado and a Hall of Fame cornerback. Despite the buzz, Sanders wasn’t among the first 32 picks, as Jaxson Dart became the second quarterback selected. While Sanders’ drop was anticipated, he remains a strong candidate to hear his name called early in the second round. Don’t be surprised if a team makes a move to snag this Heisman Trophy finalist.
Mike Green, EDGE, Marshall
Mike Green could easily claim the title of one of the draft’s most explosive pass rushers. After finishing as the leader in the FBS with 17 sacks, as well as racking up an impressive 84 total tackles, he showcased the type of talent that typically garners a top-15 pick. However, teams seemed hesitant due to off-field concerns surrounding sexual assault allegations during his college career, as well as in high school. If a franchise feels confident in Green’s rehabilitation, he could turn out to be a significant steal in this draft.
Will Johnson, CB, Michigan
Will Johnson earned recognition as one of the premier cover corners available, displaying a football IQ that enables him to make plays when opportunities arise. So, what caused his fall from Round 1? Johnson has been battling a knee injury that raised red flags for teams, compounded by shoulder and toe issues last season. His absence at Michigan’s Pro Day due to a hamstring issue only added to the worries. There’s no doubt he has the talent; it’s just a matter of when he’ll hear his name as teams head into Day 2.
Nick Emmanwori, S, South Carolina
Nick Emmanwori brings an impressive array of skills to the safety position, mixing physicality in the box with the coverage ability to handle tight ends. He is ready to step onto an NFL field as a Week 1 starter. However, the safety position has not traditionally seen high selections, with only Malaki Starks heard at pick No. 27 in the first round. Emmanwori stands poised to emerge as a valuable pick for the team that lands him in the second round.
Donovan Ezeiruaku, EDGE, Boston College
While there might have been a debate over whether Donovan Ezeiruaku deserved a first-round selection, his college production certainly warranted a Day 1 grade. He chalked up solid stats, ranking among the top three in the FBS with 16.5 sacks and 20.5 tackles for loss. Concerns linger about his height and frame, but his sack production is undeniable. Ezeiruaku is a developing prospect but could serve as a strong edge rotation player, likely to be picked early in the second round.
As the dust settles and teams reassess their boards, these players may turn out to be some of the best value picks of the entire draft. Each brings a unique skill set and potential to make an impact, and it’ll be fascinating to see where they land as the draft continues.
