Joe Milton III to Replace Geno Smith as Seahawks Starting QB

Jan 5, 2025; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; New England Patriots quarterback Joe Milton III (19) runs against the Buffalo Bills during the first half at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brian Fluharty-Imagn Images

In the ever-evolving landscape of the NFL, one name that’s quickly gaining traction is Joe Milton III. The second-year quarterback for the New England Patriots is currently under contract for the next three years, but whispers of a potential trade are beginning to surface, as reported by NFL insider Greg A. Bedard. For teams in need of a quarterback, Milton presents an intriguing opportunity.

Looking at Milton’s 2024 performance, he truly shined during his last regular season game. While he faced a Buffalo Bills squad resting key players for the playoffs, he showcased his skills in a way that made fans sit up and take notice. Completing 22 of 29 passes for 241 yards and a touchdown, along with a rushing touchdown, he demonstrated efficiency that was hard to ignore. But more than the numbers, it’s Milton’s physical attributes that have scouts buzzing. Standing at 6’5″ and weighing 235 pounds, he has one of the most naturally gifted throwing arms in the game today. He also displayed an impressive ability to elude pressure, showing that his athleticism is comparable to some of the league’s elite quarterbacks. It’s precisely these traits that should get teams searching for their next QB excited.

Of course, this isn’t just a flash in the pan. Milton started turning heads in preseason action against the Carolina Panthers, going 4 of 6 for 52 yards and another touchdown. Though it wasn’t against top-tier competition, the raw talent he displayed suggests that he could be a worthwhile investment for any team looking to bolster its quarterback room.

Now, why was Milton picked in the sixth round? His college career paints a more complicated picture. While he showed incredible potential, his inconsistency as a passer often held him back. After spending six seasons in college, one would expect a more polished quarterback, yet Milton struggled with touch and accuracy—issues that kept him grounded in the later rounds of the draft. He was known for throwing fastballs that made receptions a challenge for his receivers, but he also had standout moments, particularly in Tennessee’s RPO-heavy offense. His athleticism made him a dual threat; defenders had to respect both his arm and his capability to make plays with his legs.

A standout performance against Alabama further highlights his potential. In that game, Milton displayed his ability to deliver under pressure, converting on critical third and fourth downs, and showcasing that rocket arm.

As for a potential trade, we can look at historical precedent. Notable quarterbacks like Jimmy Garoppolo and Teddy Bridgewater have moved for second and third-round picks, respectively. Given Milton’s trajectory, a trade might yield a similar return—a second-round pick seems optimistic, but a combination of a third and a fifth round could be a reasonable middle ground.

Turning to potential landing spots, the Seattle Seahawks could make sense for a quarterback like Milton. With Geno Smith on an expiring contract and a new head coach in Mike MacDonald, the team is likely considering what its future looks like at the quarterback position. The Seahawks have shown interest in younger talent and could see Milton as a chance to invest in an ascending player without the cost of a first-round pick. This pathway allows Seattle to explore its options for a franchise quarterback without the immediate pressures that come with a top draft selection.

Overall, Joe Milton III stands at a fascinating crossroads in his young career. Whether the Patriots choose to keep him or he finds a new home, there’s no denying the potential he has to carve out a significant role in the league. For teams desperate for a spark under center, he just might be the ticket.