The Detroit Lions found themselves amid a challenging 2024 season where injuries ravaged their defense, impacting their Super Bowl aspirations. If there was a spot to point to as a potential weakness—even in good health—it would have been at cornerback. Yet, through the turmoil, Carlton Davis emerged as a beacon of stability, making his impending free agency a pressing concern for the Lions.
Davis stood out among a wavering secondary, racking up an impressive 74.5 Pro Football Focus grade, which placed him 29th at his position. In stark contrast, first-round rookie Terrion Arnold from Alabama struggled to find his footing, finishing the season with a disappointing PFF score of 51.5, ranking 179th among cornerbacks. For a player chosen in the first round, those numbers simply do not meet expectations.
As the Lions look ahead, the critical nature of re-signing Davis cannot be overstated. Leaning on Arnold as their CB1 in 2025 would spell disaster for a defense aiming to compete at the highest levels. The Lions are in an advantageous position, as Davis is not only the top cornerback on the market but is also under 30, meaning he still has plenty of good football ahead of him. While acquiring Davis may come with a steep price tag, the Lions must be willing to invest in this key position to bolster a defense that needs help.
Moreover, the Lions might consider doubling down in free agency or eyeing a high draft pick to secure another cornerback. With Campbell and his aggressive coaching style at the helm, alongside a dynamic offense, Detroit is positioned as one of the most exciting teams in football. This might just be the kind of formidable environment that entices Davis to stay, even if offers from other teams come knocking.
Davis, who previously lifted the Lombardi Trophy with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, understands the allure of winning championships. The experience of reaching the pinnacle of the NFL is intoxicating, and every player yearns for more once they’ve snagged that first ring. Plus, Davis has already expressed strong admiration for head coach Dan Campbell, labeling him his favorite coach ever. That kind of loyalty could play a significant role in Davis’s decision-making process.
Currently, the New York Jets are the other main contender rumored to have an interest in signing Davis, motivated perhaps by their new head coach, Aaron Glenn, who is familiar with Davis’s capabilities. However, the Jets are in a rebuild mode and would face an uphill battle against the Lions’ powerful emerging squad that shows promise for a future playoff run.
In the end, the Lions must acknowledge their vulnerabilities and take action. Allowing their best cornerback to slip away would be a misstep they can’t afford. If the goal is indeed to chase after that coveted Super Bowl, re-signing Carlton Davis should be at the top of their to-do list.
