Every NFL offseason brings its share of surprises, and for the Cincinnati Bengals, fourth-round pick Barrett Carter is one rookie who’s demanding attention. During the 2025 Organized Team Activities (OTAs), Carter has not just flashed his skills on the field but has also demonstrated rare leadership qualities for a first-year player. In a locker room filled with experienced veterans and more heralded draft picks, his voice, work ethic, and versatility have set him apart in a big way.
Navigating a Complex Offseason
Entering the 2025 offseason, the Bengals had a mix of stability and uncertainty. On one hand, the front office successfully secured long-term contracts for superstar wide receivers Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, ensuring that quarterback Joe Burrow’s go-to targets remain intact. However, beneath this offensive security lay deeper concerns. The Bengals’ interior offensive line is still a known vulnerability, a topic that must be addressed as they aim for a successful season.
On the defensive front, the team took significant swings during free agency and the draft. They bid farewell to long-time defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo, adding layers of unpredictability to a unit that was already experiencing turnover. Recognizing the need for reinforcements, the Bengals focused on bolstering their front seven by selecting Shemar Stewart, Demetrius Knight Jr., and Carter in the draft. Unfortunately, both Stewart and Knight faced contract negotiations during their rookie minicamp, which opened the door for others to impress — and nobody has seized that opportunity quite like Carter.
Barrett Carter Rising to the Occasion
With the absence of the top defensive draft picks, Carter has stepped up as an unexpected leader among his peers. Observers have noticed him taking charge during drills, consistently at the forefront and vocal on the field, a behavior more characteristic of seasoned veterans than a fourth-round rookie.
Despite being selected 119th overall, Carter plays with a confidence that belies his draft position. For him, the numbers don’t define his capability; instead, it’s all about the production and effort he brings to the field. His leadership is obvious, and coaches and teammates are taking note. With every practice session, Carter is reinforcing the message that he’s not just here to participate; he’s here to compete.
A Strong Show at Clemson
Carter’s impressive college career at Clemson is worth highlighting. In his senior season, he racked up 82 total tackles, including 11 tackles for loss. Adding to his credentials, he recorded 3.5 sacks and defended seven passes — proof of his ability to impact both the run and the pass game. This production reveals a glimpse into Carter’s potential at the NFL level.
His versatility is another key attribute. Unlike many players who excel in only one aspect of the game, Carter can contribute in multiple ways. His college tape reveals sharp instincts, agile mobility in coverage, and a keen ability to read plays as they develop. In today’s pass-heavy NFL, those traits are hugely valuable.
The Bengals’ strategy in the 2025 draft of selecting two linebackers with contrasting strengths underscores a thoughtful approach. While Knight is seen as the future heir to Germaine Pratt, Carter brings a different dynamic to the table. As defensive coordinator Al Golden has emphasized, a modern NFL linebacker needs the ability to impact at least two of three key areas: stopping the run, defending the pass, and contributing to special teams. Knight is strong in the run game and special teams, but Carter excels in pass coverage while still being competent in stopping the run.
In essence, Carter is well-suited to step into a hybrid role akin to what Akeem Davis-Gaither and nickel defender Mike Hilton previously held. His skill set makes him capable of covering tight ends and running backs, providing crucial flexibility during passing situations.
Opportunity on the Horizon
Timing in the NFL can be everything, and for Carter, the timing couldn’t be more opportune. With key rookies sidelined and a new defensive coordinator evaluating talent through a fresh lens, Carter’s standout performances have put him in a favorable position to secure a meaningful role during training camp and the preseason.
This offseason has brought significant change to an already evolving linebacker group. While Logan Wilson remains the cornerstone, depth and rotational positions are up for grabs. If Carter keeps up his current trajectory, expect him to see valuable snaps on passing downs, special teams, and potentially even in base packages as the season unfolds.
A Potential Steal for the Bengals
It’s still early in the offseason, and a lot can shift as training camp approaches. But Carter is certainly doing everything right thus far. He’s preparing like a veteran, performing like a seasoned pro, and displaying the leadership qualities coaches seek. For a fourth-round pick, that’s about as good as it gets.
Amidst a Bengals offseason filled with uncertainty, Carter’s emergence shines as one of the brighter spots. While top draft picks navigate their own contract negotiations, Carter is quietly showing that sometimes the biggest surprises emerge after Day 2. If he continues this trajectory, Barrett Carter may not only secure a spot on the 53-man roster but could also play a crucial role in keeping Cincinnati’s defense competitive in 2025.
