In the world of NFL contracts, especially when it comes to edge rushers like the Bengals’ Trey Hendrickson, the negotiation table can be a tricky place. With a compensation package of just $16 million for 2025, Hendrickson is understandably seeking more — and he’s been vocal about it. It goes beyond simply wanting a higher average annual value; it’s also about the structure of the deal.
According to recent reports, the crux of the matter lies in the fully-guaranteed money at signing. The Bengals have a well-documented trend of approaching contract negotiations, particularly with players who aren’t quarterbacks, with a somewhat rigid stance, typically guaranteeing only the first year of a deal. This practice stands in stark contrast to the contracts signed by other elite pass rushers this season, many of whom secured guarantees extending over three years, whether at signing or in practical terms.
Interestingly, while Hendrickson’s situation appears contentious, it’s worth noting that the Bengals did extend receiver Ja’Marr Chase a three-year fully guaranteed deal in a practical sense. Similarly, Tee Higgins finds himself with a little over one season guaranteed, which raises questions about how the Bengals prioritize their negotiations with different positions.
On the financial front, months ago, rumors hinted that the Bengals offered Hendrickson $28 million, but he is clearly aiming higher, seeking a deal that places him in the range of Maxx Crosby, who currently sits at $35.5 million per year. While the contracts of Myles Garrett ($40 million annually) and T.J. Watt ($41 million) may seem out of reach, they certainly make Hendrickson’s aspirations for Crosby-level money seem more reasonable by comparison.
However, the Bengals’ front office has a reputation for being somewhat obstinate in negotiations, which could complicate matters for Hendrickson. It leaves us to wonder if they’ll adapt their approach or continue to embody the characteristic caution that has marked their dealings, particularly concerning players who make significant contributions on the field. In this high-stakes environment, it’s clear that both sides need to find common ground, or the ongoing negotiation could drag out longer than either party would prefer.
