The Cleveland Guardians find themselves in an intriguing position as the trade deadline approaches. Unlike last season, where they were confidently dealing from a position of strength 23 games above .500, this year’s circumstances are a bit more muddled. With their current standing, it’s plausible that the Guardians might choose a variety of paths, and the whispers of potential trades are starting to sound more like a chorus. Let’s look at five Guardians players who could be packing their bags before the deadline.
LHP Logan Allen: With a record of 3-3 and a 4.22 ERA over 49 innings, Logan Allen’s journey with the Guardians has been a roller-coaster. From a promising start in 2023 to a challenging 2024 season, Allen’s recent form shows flashes of brilliance but lacks consistency. His strong start this year, boasting a 2.11 ERA through four outings, quickly gave way to a rough patch with a 5.86 ERA over seven appearances. While he might not grab a top return solo, Allen’s left-hand play and versatility in either starting or relieving roles could sweeten a larger trade deal. At just 26, there’s still time for him to refine his game, but it’s looking unlikely that the Guardians see him as a cornerstone moving forward.
OF Chase DeLauter: With a slash line of .180/.339/.400, 3 homers, and 5 RBIs across Double-A and Triple-A, DeLauter’s potential is palpable. A top-30 prospect according to MLB Pipeline, the Guardians’ No. 2 prospect has been hindered by injuries, which have delayed his ascent to the majors. The history of the Guardians shows a willingness to pull the trigger on major trades, and given DeLauter’s natural abilities, he could be the key to landing a significant player at the deadline. While injuries have slightly diminished his trade value, teams will undoubtedly have their eyes on his potential for development.
LHP Tim Herrin: Sporting a 4-1 record and a 3.80 ERA through 21 1/3 innings, Herrin’s past success in the bullpen makes him a valuable trade asset. His performance this season, marred by inconsistency and high walk rates, still holds appeal, especially given his effectiveness against left-handed hitters. With teams always on the hunt for reliable bullpen arms as they head into the postseason, Herrin could bring a strong return if the Guardians choose to make a move.
RHP Jakob Junis: With a 1-1 record and a 4.76 ERA over 28 1/3 innings, Junis stands out as a candidate for a midseason relocation. Despite a strong start, his recent performances have been hit-or-miss, as hitters are finding success against his mix. Known for their pitching prospects, the Guardians have room for others to fill his role, making Junis expendable at the deadline.
OF Lane Thomas: Currently hitting .119/.169/.136 with no home runs and 3 RBIs in 17 games, Thomas’s journey with the Guardians could be nearing its end due to injuries and inconsistent performance. Acquired last year to bolster their push for success, Thomas’s time in Cleveland has been underwhelming, punctuated by moments of brilliance like his postseason heroics. As an impending free agent, trading him could ensure the Guardians recoup some value before he potentially explores free agency, though any move would depend heavily on the team’s outlook by the end of July.
As we look ahead, these potential moves showcase the Guardians’ need to balance immediate competitiveness with a view toward future success. Whether they position themselves as buyers, sellers, or something in between, the decisions they make at this trade deadline will resonate throughout the organization for years to come.
