In today’s edition of “First Call,” there’s plenty of buzz surrounding the Steelers’ recent trade of George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys. As we unpack this trade, we also delve into some noteworthy developments involving former players, including an exciting honor for Maurkice Pouncey and a concerning legal matter for Aaron Donald.
Steelers’ Shift: Are They Tanking?
The fallout from the Pickens trade has sparked significant discussion, particularly from former Steeler Ryan Clark, who voiced his concerns on ESPN’s “Get Up.” Clark didn’t mince words: he suggested that the Steelers might be entering a tanking phase. “I know they are, because they’ve made other moves,” he said. He added that the current roster lacks the depth and talent needed for a winning season, remaining skeptical about their playoff prospects.
If this season goes sideways for the Steelers, it would mark their first losing record since 2003—a year that saw them finish 6-10 and draft Ben Roethlisberger with the 11th overall pick.
Clark’s take reflects a larger sentiment that what we’ve been witnessing in Pittsburgh isn’t just a rebuild—it could signify a significant shift in philosophy. He expressed trust in general manager Omar Khan and head coach Mike Tomlin but voiced doubts about the team’s immediate future. “This isn’t a team I’d put any money on,” Clark quipped, underscoring his skepticism about their current trajectory.
But let’s clarify: the term “tanking” carries a heavy connotation, and while the Steelers’ trade strategy is certainly under scrutiny, it may be more a matter of mismanagement than outright intent to lose. By trading Pickens—who was a key contributor last season—the Steelers have raised eyebrows about their commitment to compete this season. Instead of adding to their roster pre-draft or securing another wide receiver, they opted for a future draft pick in 2026, a decision that leaves many rethinking the overall direction of the franchise.
A Historic First for the Steelers
Here’s a striking stat to consider: this could be the first time in the 92-year history of the Steelers that they’ll start a season without last year’s leading passer, rusher, and receiver. Last year, Russell Wilson, Najee Harris, and Pickens stood atop those categories, but all are now elsewhere as the Steelers head into 2025.
This shakeup has led to mixed interpretations of the Steelers’ strategy. NFL insider Jonathan Jones remarked on the clarity surrounding Pickens’ departure, noting that the team had signaled intentions to move on from him even before trading for DK Metcalf. This gives credence to the idea that Pickens’ trade was part of a larger plan that has been in the works.
The trade has put the Steelers in a favorable draft position, as they now project to possess five picks within the first two days of the upcoming NFL Draft, including a first-round selection and three third-rounders, plus a compensatory pick expected from Justin Fields’ departure.
Pouncey’s New Honor
On a positive note, former Steelers center Maurkice Pouncey received a well-deserved accolade this week as he was inducted into the University of Florida Athletics Hall of Fame. Pouncey’s impact on the Gators was immense, as he was a starting offensive lineman from 2007 to 2009, playing a pivotal role in their 2008 National Championship win and earning the Rimington Trophy for being the nation’s top center.
He transitioned to the NFL as the Steelers’ first-round draft pick in 2010 and went on to carve out a stellar career, ultimately being named a two-time All-Pro and participating in nine Pro Bowls. His legacy in Pittsburgh remains a significant part of NFL history.
Donald Seeks Legal Protection
In another notable story, former Pitt standout Aaron Donald is grappling with a troubling situation regarding a stalking incident. The retired Rams star has secured a restraining order against a woman who has allegedly been harassing him for several years. According to his legal team, this restraining order spans five years, following a temporary order secured just last month.
Donald’s complaint describes a troubling pattern of harassment that began back in 2020. He documented incidents of unwanted communication and even threats against his family, emphasizing that this situation is more than just an inconvenience—it’s a serious infringement on his safety. This legal turmoil adds another layer to Donald’s already complex post-career life.
As the NFL landscape continues to shift, these stories remind us of the weighty decisions that teams face and the personal challenges athletes can encounter off the field. The coming months will certainly be telling for the Steelers and their new direction, and we’ll be keeping a close eye on how these narratives unfold.
