Is Milroe REALLY a Good Fit For The Giants?

The New York Giants have hinted at a strategic shift regarding their quarterback position heading into the 2025 NFL Draft. Despite bolstering their roster by signing veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston in free agency, Giants General Manager Joe Schoen has made it clear that the team is under no immediate pressure to pick a quarterback early, particularly not at their third overall selection.

Schoen emphasized that the team’s current setup allows them to be selective: “We don’t have to take a QB. If it matches up, if the value is right, we’ll consider it.” This perspective suggests a calculated approach as they look to reinforce their future without succumbing to the urgency that sometimes accompanies draft decisions.

Instead of reaching for a quarterback in the early rounds, the Giants seem inclined to explore options later in the draft, with a particular eye on Jalen Milroe, a talented dual-threat quarterback emerging as a prime candidate. While this is not an official report, it reflects the Giants’ ongoing assessment of their needs and opportunities.

The Giants have been weighing the quarterback position since midseason when they parted ways with Daniel Jones. As the draft approaches, they are evaluating their options carefully, knowing they could find valuable talent to build around. Free agency moves indicate that the Giants may be looking to strengthen their roster across multiple positions before settling on a quarterback, suggesting they’re poised to be strategic rather than reactive.

Jalen Milroe has been making noise through his college career at Alabama, where he recorded impressive stats over two years as a starter. He threw for over 2,000 yards each season, including 2,834 yards and 16 touchdowns in his most recent year, although he faced challenges with consistency at times. Milroe’s ability as a dual-threat quarterback was also on display, with 879 rushing yards and 20 touchdowns last season, which complements his overall career total of 2,038 rushing yards and 33 touchdowns.

For the Giants, selecting Milroe could be a gamble worth taking. He is recognized as a raw prospect and will undoubtedly need proper development to reach his potential at the NFL level. His journey would benefit immensely from the guidance of seasoned quarterbacks like Wilson and Winston, who could help ensure he’s not thrust into the starting role too soon.

By investing in Milroe, the Giants would be betting on untapped potential—a move reminiscent of how the Buffalo Bills approached Josh Allen when Brian Daboll was part of the coaching staff. With Milroe’s dual-threat capabilities and athleticism, he would provide an exciting element to the Giants’ offense, aligning with the kind of ingenuity that Daboll has thrived on in his coaching career.

As the Giants prepare for the draft, the choices they make now will resonate for years to come, and Jalen Milroe stands as a symbol of the potential future they are crafting.