The Denver Broncos, a franchise steeped in football history, have seen their fair share of ups and downs in recent years. Fans might find it hard to remember the sustained success the team enjoyed for so long, particularly following Peyton Manning’s retirement after winning Super Bowl 50, which marked the beginning of a challenging era. Despite recent struggles, it’s vital to recognize that the Broncos once boasted the third-highest winning percentage in the NFL during the 16-game era.
Throughout their storied existence, the Broncos have been home to two of the greatest quarterbacks in league history, along with a roster of stars who not only shaped the franchise but also revolutionized the game itself. The team’s success over decades can be attributed to the contributions of remarkable athletes on both ends of the ball.
Although their Hall of Fame representation has lagged in the past, several Broncos legends have recently received their due recognition, bringing the franchise’s Hall of Famers up to 15, with 14 being former players. As the team prepares for the 2025 NFL Draft, it’s time to take a closer look at the Top 10 players in Denver Broncos history.
10. Karl Mecklenburg (LB, 1983-1994)
When it comes to great linebackers, Karl Mecklenburg stands tall. The “Albino Rhino” was far more than just a linebacker; he was a true defensive chameleon. With the ability to excel at every position in the front seven, Mecklenburg was a force against the run and a viable threat as a pass rusher. He ranks second in franchise history with 1,104 tackles and third with 79 sacks, showcasing his dynamic skill set. A six-time Pro Bowler, his contributions were pivotal in driving the Broncos to three Super Bowl appearances in the ’80s.
9. Randy Gradishar (LB, 1974-1983)
Anchoring the famed “Orange Crush” defense, Randy Gradishar was essential in turning the Broncos into a respected and feared team during the late ’70s and early ’80s. Known for his relentless playing style, Gradishar’s defense set the tone for a successful era, leading the team to its first Super Bowl appearance in 1977. While official tackle records weren’t kept during his career, estimates suggest he racked up about 2,049 tackles—figures that would’ve certainly elevated his place among the franchise’s greats.
8. Rod Smith (WR, 1994-2007)
Before Demaryius Thomas stole the spotlight, Rod Smith was dazzling fans with his precise route-running and reliable hands. Smith holds the franchise records for receiving yards (11,389), receptions (849), and receiving touchdowns (68). Even more impressive was his ability to thrive independent of quarterback John Elway, demonstrating his skill by leading the league in receptions in 2001, the year following Elway’s retirement. An undrafted gem, Smith has secured his place among the greats in Broncos history and is celebrated as one of the best undrafted players the NFL has ever seen.
7. Steve Atwater (S, 1989-1998)
Steve Atwater made a name for himself as one of the hardest-hitting safeties of all time. His infamous tackle on the Kansas City Chiefs’ Christian Okoye serves as a perfect example of his intense playing style. With eight Pro Bowls to his name, Atwater’s defensive prowess contributed greatly to two Super Bowl victories. In his career, he recorded 24 interceptions, proving himself not just as a hammer on opposing ball carriers but also as a solid coverage option.
6. Shannon Sharpe (TE, 1990-1999, 2002-2003)
Shannon Sharpe revolutionized the tight end position, providing a new standard centered more on pass-catching than blocking. With 8,439 of his 10,060 career receiving yards coming with the Broncos, Sharpe etched his name into the franchise record books, along with securing 675 receptions and 55 touchdowns. He’s regarded among the elite at his position, with a strong argument for a place in the top five of all time.
5. Von Miller (LB, 2011-2021)
From day one, Von Miller proved to be a game-changer for the Broncos. Drafted second overall in 2011, his quick transitions from rookie to elite pass rusher were remarkable. With a franchise record of 110.5 sacks, Miller’s unmatched speed and strength redefined edge rushing. The “No Fly Zone” defense wouldn’t have reached its legendary status without him leading the charge, forcing quarterbacks into hasty decisions that allowed the secondary to shine. His crowning achievement came in the 2015 season when he not only won Super Bowl 50 but also earned MVP honors, solidifying his legacy in Denver.
4. Terrell Davis (RB, 1995-2002)
Initially overlooked during the draft, Terrell Davis changed the narrative, blazing a trail from special teams standout to one of the NFL’s all-time great running backs. His historic performance in Super Bowl XXXII, where he rushed for seven touchdowns in the postseason and claimed MVP honors, showcased his capability under pressure. Even after a prime cut short by injuries, Davis left an indelible mark on the game, highlighted by his 2,000-yard rushing season, an extraordinary feat.
3. Champ Bailey (CB, 2004-2013)
Often regarded as one of the NFL’s most underrated players, Champ Bailey is viewed by many as the best cornerback in league history. With twelve Pro Bowl nods and a staggering 203 passes defended, Bailey’s prowess in coverage forced offenses to rethink their strategies. His 2006 season was legendary, allowing just four receptions while leading the league with ten interceptions, defining a career that exemplified defensive excellence.
2. Peyton Manning (QB, 2012-2015)
Peyton Manning’s impact on the Broncos franchise is undeniable. In just four seasons, he transformed the organization, setting an impeccable standard for quarterback play. During the 2013 season, he established the record for single-season passing yards and touchdowns, leading a historic offensive unit. Even though he faced challenges from injuries before joining the Broncos, Manning proved doubters wrong with his stellar performances, wrapping up his career with another championship and a reputation that etched him as one of the most iconic figures in NFL history.
1. John Elway (QB, 1983-1998)
No discussion of Denver Broncos legends is complete without mentioning John Elway. A one-of-a-kind talent, he wielded a powerful arm and the agility of an elite running back, making him a nightmare for opposing defenses. Elway’s career passing numbers remain unmatched in franchise history, and his role in leading the team to five Super Bowl appearances remains legendary. After overcoming early career criticisms about not sealing the deal, Elway capped off his tenure perfectly, winning back-to-back titles in his final two seasons, sealing his legacy as one of the greatest players to ever grace the game.
As we reflect on these iconic figures, it’s clear that the Denver Broncos’ history is rich with talent and success. Amid their current challenges, this franchise’s legacy continues to inspire new generations of players and fans alike.
