Derek Carr finds himself in an intriguing situation with the New Orleans Saints, where he’s locked into a contract for the next two seasons that carries hefty cap hits of $50 million and $60 million. With new head coach Kellen Moore expressing unwavering support for him, it’s a relationship worth monitoring, especially considering the financial implications. However, for a team that may want to shake things up, the idea of moving on from Carr might not be as far-fetched as one might think.
The Steelers: A Potential Fit for Carr
When evaluating potential landing spots for Carr, the Pittsburgh Steelers emerge as a compelling candidate. Currently, they’re in need of a starting quarterback, especially with both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields set to hit free agency. While acquiring Carr may seem like a pragmatic approach, it raises the question of whether he’s a better fit compared to Wilson or Fields for this Steelers offense.
The Steelers have shown hesitance about maintaining Fields after a mixed bag of performances. Despite a respectable 10-1 touchdown-to-interception ratio over five games, Fields was benched, indicating a preference within the organization for a more seasoned signal-caller. That leaves Carr as a realistic option, particularly in Mike Tomlin’s scheme, where experience and a more traditional pocket-passing style could be valued.
A Trade Proposal on the Horizon?
The Saints’ current predicament is compounded by Carr’s daunting contract, which may limit their return if they decide to trade him. Realistically, they might not fetch more than a third or fourth-round pick. Still, if the Saints can persuade a team like the Steelers to absorb Carr’s contract with an additional fourth-round selection, it could provide a much-needed financial reprieve.
For the Saints, shedding Carr’s salary could signal the beginning of a rebuild. After years of navigating their “Cap Hell,” general manager Mickey Loomis faces a pivotal offseason. Moving on from Carr could catalyze their transition towards new talent, potentially allowing them to secure a younger quarterback through the draft, such as a Justin Fields, Joe Milton, or Jaxson Dart—players with fresh potential who can lead the franchise into a new era.
The Road Ahead
While Carr’s tenure in New Orleans has seen flashes of success, especially during healthier stretches, the long-term outlook under a new head coach at 34 years old appears limited. If the Saints feel the time is right to embrace a rebuilding phase, cutting ties with Carr could be their gateway to revitalizing the roster and pursuing a more youthful, dynamic signal-caller. For Steelers fans and the front office, this offseason could bring a mix of uncertainty and opportunity, making it one to watch closely.
