Trevor Lawrence Is The Reason For The Jacksonville Jaguars Failure, Not Doug Peterson

Dec 1, 2024; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence (16) runs with the ball against the Houston Texans in the second quarter at EverBank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

After a disappointing 4-13 finish in the 2024 season, the Jacksonville Jaguars have decided to part ways with head coach Doug Pederson. The tumultuous season saw setbacks due to key player absences, most notably Trevor Lawrence, making it evident that a shift was necessary. Lawrence, once hailed as a generational talent, appeared to stall in development, indicating a deeper systemic issue as the team found itself in a state of self-destruction more often than not. With a roster built to contend immediately, the Jaguars now face the challenge of navigating a head coaching search amidst uncertainty.

The Jaguars’ head coaching search hasn’t started on the easiest foot. The door closed on two prominent offensive minds when Ben Johnson, formerly the Detroit Lions’ offensive coordinator, was scooped up by the Chicago Bears, and Liam Coen, the Buccaneers’ offensive coordinator, opted to remain in Tampa Bay with a lucrative extension. This leaves the Jaguars digging deeper to find the right fit—perhaps one who can resurrect an offense struggling to meet its potential.

Amidst this turbulence, it’s tempting to pin the entire blame on Trevor Lawrence. His 2024 campaign, marred by injuries and a completion rate stuck at 60%, fell short of expectations set by his college reputation. The weight of a five-year, $275 million extension adds pressure, but the picture is far from simple. Lawrence was pushed into a volatile environment, starting with the infamous Urban Meyer saga, compounded by questionable personnel moves. The result? Preparing to welcome a third coach in five years—a significant disruption to any budding NFL career.

The roots of Jacksonville’s woes might extend into the front office, where GM Trent Baalke’s influence over coaching hires comes under scrutiny. Known for his strong involvement and a history of tension with coaches, Baalke’s leadership has yet to translate into sustained success. The Jaguars have circled through coaches and left critical roster gaps unfilled, suggesting that a philosophical overhaul may be the necessary starting point to rebuild the franchise’s foundations.

Looking forward, the Jaguars are considering respected names like Patrick Graham and Robert Salah. These candidates bring respected pedigree and leadership potential necessary for steering Jacksonville back on course. Even with some top prospects slipping away, there remains hope in the ability of the Jaguars to turn things around by making strategic, thoughtful decisions at this pivotal juncture.