The Michigan Wolverines find themselves navigating a tumultuous 2025 season, with new head coach Sherrone Moore facing a two-game suspension wrapped in the shadow of a lingering NCAA sign-stealing investigation from 2023. This action, publicly announced by the university, shows a commitment to compliance in an increasingly scrutinized environment. Unlike his predecessor, Jim Harbaugh, who managed to coach practices during his own suspensions before heading to the NFL’s Los Angeles Chargers, Moore will step away entirely from the team during his ban, which affects key matchups against Fresno State and Arkansas State in September. This situation has already ignited conversations about Moore’s future and the potential for a fresh start at Michigan.
Moore, who took the reins in January 2024 following Harbaugh’s departure, has been implicated in the same sign-stealing scandal that led to harsh consequences for Michigan football. The NCAA’s probing not only resulted in Harbaugh receiving a three-game suspension but also saw the treasured 2023 national title vacated. Moore’s involvement, highlighted by the exchange of 52 text messages with Connor Stalions—the staff member reportedly at the heart of the operation—has prompted Michigan to act decisively by imposing this suspension in an effort to lessen any future sanctions from the NCAA. The university has focused on emphasizing “accountability,” a move that restricts Moore from participating in all team-related activities, including practices and games, marking a more stringent approach compared to Harbaugh’s sideline bans.
As the Wolverines gear up for the 2025 season, their prospects look somewhat bleak with ESPN’s FPI predicting an 8-4 record. Much rides on Moore’s ability to move past the previous season’s turmoil. The team returns key players such as quarterback Alex Orji, who threw for 1,876 yards and had 12 touchdowns in 2024, alongside running back Donovan Edwards, who contributed 822 rushing yards and 7 touchdowns. However, last year’s underwhelming 7-5 finish—capped by a Citrus Bowl loss to Alabama—left fans yearning for a rekindling of the 2023 season’s magic, when they went a remarkable 15-0. Compounding the situation is the cloud of uncertainty stemming from the sign-stealing scandal and a recruiting class that ranked just 22nd, along with notable transfer losses that have deflated some excitement around the program.
In light of this challenging environment, there have been calls for a “top-down restart” within the Wolverines’ ranks, with one notably bold suggestion emerging: the possibility of bringing in Jon Gruden—the former Super Bowl-winning coach—as Moore’s successor. Although largely conjecture, Gruden’s credentials as a seasoned football mind remain impressive. He boasts a 117-112 NFL record and a Super Bowl title with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2002. Despite his tumultuous exit from the Las Vegas Raiders in 2021 over offensive emails from his prior ESPN tenure, Gruden has kept his football knowledge sharp through various platforms, including mentoring draft prospects and producing insightful film breakdowns that are widely viewed on YouTube.
Gruden’s connection to the Wolverines could hinge on his renowned charisma and recruiting prowess. Historically, his offenses ranked among the best in the NFL during his tenure, and Michigan’s offense, which ranked 74th in yards last season, could benefit immensely from his experience. Utilizing Orji’s dual-threat capabilities and the talents of tight end Colston Loveland could reinvigorate a struggling unit. Furthermore, with Michigan’s robust NIL collective backing and high brand value, Gruden would have the resources necessary to compete at the highest level in recruiting against powerhouses like Ohio State and Alabama.
However, while exploring this potential switch, it’s essential to acknowledge the hurdles that may accompany Gruden’s hypothetical hiring. His past controversies, particularly the derogatory emails that led to his departure from the NFL, raise significant concerns regarding public relations, especially given Michigan’s progressive campus values. Additionally, Gruden’s lack of recent college coaching experience could be a challenge in the contemporary landscape that emphasizes adapting to NIL opportunities and the transfer portal dynamics.
On the flip side, Moore isn’t out of the picture just yet. His inaugural season, though disappointing, included notable victories against ranked opponents like USC and Minnesota. His proven track record as offensive coordinator prior to stepping into the head coach role shows promise, especially given the organizational stability he has maintained with the coaching staff. There’s always the chance that this suspension, occurring at the beginning of the season, allows him to return for crucial Big Ten matchups and demonstrate that he can guide Michigan through this adversity.
Moreover, the challenges Michigan faces this season don’t appear insurmountable. With a snapshot of their roster and promising offensive stats—such as their third-ranked rushing attack—a foundation exists upon which Moore can build. The Wolverines remain contenders for bowl eligibility with several winnable games ahead, and ultimately, a successful return could help his case significantly.
As the clock ticks toward the start of the season on September 6, it’s clear that Sherrone Moore’s narrative is far from over. The Wolverines face a critical year ahead, uncertain yet filled with potential as they seek to navigate these choppy waters and emerge resilient—whether it’s with Moore at the helm or through a fresh face like Gruden. For now, Michigan is rallying behind Moore, betting on him to carry the team through this storm and silence the noise surrounding the sign-stealing saga.
