Maple Leafs May Reunite Brothers In A Blockbuster Trade

Maple Leafs May Reunite Brothers In A Blockbuster Trade Maple Leafs May Reunite Brothers In A Blockbuster Trade
Apr 13, 2025; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; Toronto Maple Leafs center Auston Matthews (34) goes out to the warmups before the game against the Carolina Hurricanes at Lenovo Center. Mandatory Credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

The Toronto Maple Leafs are presented with a significant chance to retool their roster, particularly in light of the recent buzz surrounding Dallas Stars forward Jason Robertson. This discussion, ignited by Canucks insider Rick Dhaliwal and further explored by Frank Seravalli of Daily Faceoff, has sent ripples through the NHL as the league grapples with the Stars’ complicated salary cap situation.

Dallas has pushed their cap constraints to the max, leaving them facing the reality of losing key players. With just under $5 million in cap space and a host of free agents on the horizon, the Stars could be eyeing a move involving Robertson, who is entering the final year of his current contract with a cap hit of $7.75 million and will be a restricted free agent next season. This opens the door for clubs like the Maple Leafs to consider making a strategic acquisition.

The idea of uniting the Robertson brothers in Toronto is tantalizing. It’s a bold move that could reshape the team’s dynamics and mitigate some of the challenges that have come with the current Core Four configuration. While trading Mitch Marner may seem drastic, it’s a calculated decision that could facilitate the arrival of Jason while still providing room for the Maple Leafs to retain promising young talent like Matthew Knies and veteran leadership in John Tavares.

From a cap management perspective, Maple Leafs general manager Brad Treliving has the opportunity to navigate this trade without sinking the franchise. The Stars’ need to make adjustments means they might not be in the strongest bargaining position, particularly with concerns about Robertson’s future commitments. Other franchises could be hesitant to trade for him, understanding the uncertainty around re-signing him.

This speculation around the potential for a Robertson reunion holds personal stakes, too. The Robertson family has already experienced the tug-of-war of having their sons on rival teams, with their mother famously donning a half-Stars, half-Leafs jersey during matchups. Envisioning Jason in a Toronto jersey would not just be a strategic win; it would also strike a sentimental chord for family and fans alike.

As for the mechanics of the deal, it’s likely that Treliving would focus on a package that doesn’t put a strain on the salary cap. The idea of including mid-tier prospects or players on league-minimum contracts could provide the Stars with sufficient incentives without complicating matters financially. Even late-round picks might sweeten the offer sufficiently for Dallas, especially with Toronto’s draft positioning not being particularly robust this year.

Ultimately, this could be a pivotal moment for the Maple Leafs and their leadership. Making a proactive move could serve as a signal of intent, potentially alleviating the ongoing Marner saga that has been a constant narrative surrounding the team. By striking while the iron is hot, Treliving can position the Leafs for a competitive next season and seize a moment of opportunity that would otherwise risk slipping through their fingers.