In a significant move that marked a turning point for the Yankees, the team has designated veteran DJ LeMahieu for assignment. This decision came shortly after Jazz Chisholm Jr. transitioned back to second base, and while it may have seemed on the horizon, it signals a broader reckoning for New York as they navigate the remainder of the season. With around $22 million owed to LeMahieu through next year, the decision wasn’t made lightly, but the soon-to-be 37-year-old has seen his skills wane in recent years and has been plagued by injuries that limited his effectiveness.
Ironically, LeMahieu had found some success in July, hitting .467 in his last 15 at-bats. Overall, though, his season statistics reflect a player whose abilities have plateaued at .266/.338/.336 with just two home runs in 45 games. Traditionally, LeMahieu’s strong glove would have justified that offensive output, but his defensive prowess has also declined. Limited by a weak arm and reduced range at second base, he no longer brings the same value defensively that he once did, and base stealing has never been part of his game.
As the trade deadline approaches, the Yankees have been in desperate need of a third baseman even before this move. With LeMahieu gone, the hot corner will likely be manned by Oswald Peraza, whose defensive skill set offers promise, albeit with limited offensive production. The team will also give additional playing time to Jorbit Vivas and JC Escarra as they attempt to patch up a roster dealing with pitching injuries to key players like Gerrit Cole, Fernando Cruz, Luis Gil, and Clarke Schmidt. It’s clear that the Yankees are facing an uphill battle and have a significant to-do list as the trade deadline looms.
“We’re looking to acquire a starter, some relief help, and ideally, an infielder as well,” General Manager Brian Cashman stated. “That’s quite the shopping list. I’m not sure how deep this trade market will be, but we aim to be active and will keep our eyes open for the right improvements.”
As the trade market begins to percolate after the amateur draft, several third basemen have emerged as potential targets for the Yankees. Here’s a look at five candidates who could provide the upgrade the team desperately needs:
Nolan Arenado, Cardinals
As the most prominent name on the trade block, Arenado was already in the Yankees’ sights during the offseason. Although a deal didn’t materialize, it’s worth noting that replacing LeMahieu with Arenado wouldn’t be a straightforward solution. While Arenado’s defense remains elite, his offensive numbers have dipped, and with a massive $40 million owed through 2027, the Yankees would need to weigh the pros and cons carefully. Still, if available, Arenado would undeniably be an immediate upgrade over Peraza and potentially reignite his offensive spark away from St. Louis.
Ke’Bryan Hayes, Pirates
With a legacy tied to the Yankees through his father, Charlie, who caught the final out of their 1996 World Series, Hayes is generating interest around the league. Renowned for his elite defensive abilities—arguably the best in baseball—Hayes has struggled offensively but remains signed through 2029 at a reasonable average of $8 million per year. If a team can unlock his potential at the plate, he could become a valuable asset.
Ryan McMahon, Rockies
Though the Rockies might be hesitant to move McMahon, the Yankees should at least put out feelers. McMahon, who turns 31 in December, has been a steady contributor defensively, even if his offense has benefitted from Coors Field. With a contract of $16 million per year through 2027, acquiring him may not seem the most sensible option for a team eyeing the future, but if the Rockies are willing to listen, New York should take the call.
Eugenio Suárez, Diamondbacks
Suárez stands out as a potentially transformative addition for the Yankees. His ability to bring middle-of-the-order power is something this lineup craves. As the Diamondbacks currently hover on the fringes of the playoff race, they might hold off on trading Suárez until they assess their postseason prospects. Nevertheless, if he becomes available, he could be the most significant enhancement the Yankees make at third base.
Ramón Urías, Orioles
As the Orioles grapple with their position in the standings under interim manager Tony Mansolino, Urías may find himself on the trade market. He boasts strong defense and has demonstrated the ability to hit left-handed pitching effectively, making him a step up from Peraza. Though not the headline-grabber some might want, Urías could provide valuable depth and stability, especially if the Orioles determine they need to move pieces to focus on the future.
As the Yankees work to reconfigure their roster, the coming weeks will be crucial for shaping the team’s trajectory. With options available and the right moves, they could turn this challenging season into a more promising outlook.
