In a compelling recent discussion, Los Angeles Dodgers All-Star Max Muncy weighed in on what truly defines a rivalry in baseball. While many passionate San Diego Padres fans may feel a deep-seated animosity toward the Dodgers, Muncy suggests that the essence of a true rivalry runs deeper than mere competitive moments on the field.
Muncy pointedly stated, “The Padres bring everything that is in a rivalry, but you only have one rival.” For him, that enduring rival is none other than the San Francisco Giants. He articulated a sentiment shared by many in the baseball community, emphasizing the historical context that shapes these rivalries. Drawing comparisons to the storied rivalry between the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox, Muncy made it clear: “If you have a rival, it’s your counterpart, and that’s always going to be the Giants for the Dodgers.”
This perspective might surprise some, especially in light of the heightened competitiveness between the Dodgers and Padres in recent seasons. The two teams have clashed multiple times in the National League Division Series since 2020, and while those encounters have been electric, Muncy argues that they lack the historical weight that defines a classic rivalry. He stated, “By definition, you can’t just decide to choose your rivalry because one team gets good… and for the Dodgers, that’ll always be the Giants.”
Much of the recent intensity surrounding the Dodgers-Padres matchup can be traced back to the 2024 NLDS, where the Padres initially took a 2-1 series lead. However, a significant moment came when L.A. faced a tough challenge after the Padres’ six-run explosion in Game 3. Despite that setback, the Dodgers rallied back and showed their mettle, eventually dominating the remainder of the series, advancing to the NLCS, and securing their eighth World Series title.
Although the Padres have emerged as fierce competitors, Muncy’s remarks remind us that the historical context—the long-standing battles and legendary moments—are what truly elevate a team to rival status. While the Dodgers and Padres are certainly creating memorable moments on the diamond, that classic rivalry vibe, filled with the weight of tradition and history, continues to firmly rest with the Giants for the Dodgers. The landscape of baseball is ever-changing, but some truths about rivalry remain timeless.
