Anthony Rizzo, the former star who famously ended the Chicago Cubs’ long championship drought in 2016, has navigated a rocky path with the New York Yankees. After a tenure in the Bronx that fell short of lofty expectations—from fans, the organization, and perhaps even himself—Rizzo finds himself at a crossroads as he heads into free agency.
Once celebrated as one of the premier first basemen of the 2010s, Rizzo struggled to maintain that All-Star level during his later years. The optimism surrounding his arrival in New York has been met with a stark reality; he hasn’t quite looked like the player who played a pivotal role in Chicago’s 2016 World Series run. Now, as he searches for a new team, the likelihood of a reunion with the Yankees seems plausible—especially given their current roster challenges.
The Yankees are already navigating a tough start to the season, exacerbated by Giancarlo Stanton’s indefinite absence. Stanton was expected to return to the lineup by May, but the uncertainty of injuries can often derail even the most optimistic timelines. With Gerrit Cole also sidelined, the Yankees’ depth is being sorely tested, and they may need to explore options in free agency or the trade market to fill these gaps.
This is where Rizzo could come back into play. Despite not delivering the production in New York that he was known for in his earlier days, Rizzo remains a seasoned Major League hitter with a wealth of playoff experience. While his numbers may not scream star status, signing him to a minimum deal could prove beneficial for the Yankees. There’s a chance he offers veteran stability during a tumultuous time, both for the locker room and on the field.
Rizzo’s capacity to contribute positively hinges on his health. If he can log 130 or more games, there’s a good likelihood that he’ll produce respectable numbers—a crucial factor for a team searching to solidify its lineup. In recent seasons, Rizzo has dealt with several injuries, which he’s actively working to overcome to make his mark in 2025.
Ultimately, while Rizzo may not have recaptured his previous glory, his experience and resilience make him a valuable asset for a franchise looking to weather the storm of injury and uncertainty. With a little luck and some strategic planning, Rizzo could once again don the Yankee pinstripes and play a significant role in a team aiming to find its footing in the highly competitive landscape of Major League Baseball.
