AL West Outlook: Which MLB Teams Will Thrive or Struggle in 2025?

Apr 16, 2024; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mike Trout (27) looks on against the Tampa Bay Rays at the end of the fifth inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-USA TODAY Sports

As we delve into the AL West, a division characterized by its unique blend of established veterans and rising stars, anticipation hangs in the air. The Houston Astros have been the dominant force, laying claim to the top spot for seven of the past eight seasons. But with the competition tightening, are we on the brink of a shake-up, or will the usual suspects maintain their hold?

Let’s break down each team in the AL West and explore how they stack up as the season unfolds.

Seattle Mariners – A Slight Decline

The Mariners are coming into this season nearly unchanged from the last, with their most notable move being the return of Jorge Polanco. While stability can be a strength, the Mariners’ relative quietness raises questions about their ability to compete.

On the pitching side, Seattle boasts one of the league’s strongest rotations, highlighted by the formidable trio of Luis Castillo, Logan Gilbert, and George Kirby. With these arms, generating runs off them will be no small feat for opposing teams. However, their offensive production has been less than stellar. Aside from rising star Julio Rodriguez, who is set to lead the charge, the lineup is lacking in impactful hitters.

The performance of guys like Randy Arozarena is crucial; after his trade from Tampa Bay, he failed to replicate his previous success. If the Mariners don’t see a significant improvement in their offensive game, they could be staring at similar results to last year.

Los Angeles Angels – A Modest Upswing

The Angels find themselves in another season of rebuilding, a cycle that seems to stretch on indefinitely. But there’s a silver lining: Mike Trout is back in action, shifting to right field in hopes that this change will keep him healthier throughout the campaign.

While the expectations for a playoff run are tempered, Los Angeles fans can look forward to a few key players to watch. Taylor Ward, coming off a 25-home run season, is poised for another solid performance, and catcher Logan O’Hoppe aims to build on a strong showing from last year, where he notched over 100 hits and 20 homers.

Additionally, the Angels have brought in newcomers Yoan Moncada and Kyle Hendricks, both of whom are hoping for bounce-back seasons. They could even become intriguing trade assets as the season progresses, depending on how well they play.

Houston Astros – A Year of Transition

The Astros are entering a transformative season after an offseason filled with significant changes, notably the departures of Alex Bregman, now with the Red Sox, and Kyle Tucker, who was traded to the Cubs. The trade sent shockwaves through the organization, but the return included promising pieces like All-Star third baseman Isaac Paredes and up-and-coming right-hander Hayden Wesneski.

With key stalwarts like Yordan Alvarez and Jose Altuve still on the roster, the Astros have a foundation but face uncertainty beyond these stars. They made a splash in free agency by signing Christian Walker, a solid bat at 34 years old, yet concerns linger over aging veterans after previous risks with players like José Abreu.

Pitching, too, poses its own set of challenges. The rotation features Lance McCullers returning from injury and Framber Valdez, but depth is questionable. Cristian Javier struggled last season, posting a 3.89 ERA, and while Hunter Brown possesses the potential, he has yet to fully harness it despite a solid strikeout tally.

With Ryan Pressly traded, the bullpen is also lacking in certainty apart from the return of closer Josh Hader. It’s a season of exploration for the Astros, as they assess their roster and redefine their competitive strategy.

Texas Rangers – Steady Rise

For the Rangers, last season was a bump in the road after their championship two years ago, finishing 78-84 and missing the playoffs for the fifth time in seven years. Yet, on paper, they have reason to be optimistic.

This offseason, they bolstered their pitching staff by adding five new arms, hoping to counteract the loss of significant players like Kirby Yates and David Robertson. Offensively, the acquisitions of Joc Pederson and Jake Burger are poised to keep the batters firing.

If Texas can navigate the health issues that hindered their previous season, they could very well find themselves back in the mix for the AL West crown.

Oakland Athletics – Gradual Improvement

The Athletics are making headlines as they wrap up their final games at the Oakland Coliseum, transitioning to a minor league park for the next three years. This follows a challenging previous season, where they finished at 69-93, narrowly escaping the basement of the division above the Angels.

This offseason, they focused on strengthening their rotation and adding depth to the bullpen, acquiring Luis Severino from the Yankees. Brent Rooker also showed promise last year and is expected to continue his upward trajectory.

Success will hinge on their ability to maintain offensive momentum and effectively integrate their new pitching talent. If everything clicks, the A’s could surprise observers and make strides in a competitive division.

As the season gets underway in the AL West, one thing is clear: each team’s journey will be filled with challenges and opportunities. It promises to be an exciting season packed with potential surprises.