The New York Yankees finally made it to the World Series in 2024, their first appearance since 2009. Yet, the championship drought continues, leaving fans wondering how much longer Aaron Boone will remain at the helm. Since taking over as manager in 2018, Boone has only missed the playoffs once, but with just one World Series appearance that ended in a loss, the Yankees’ “championship or bust” mentality raises the question of whether it’s time for a change. The buzz among the Yankees faithful is the potential for Derek Jeter to step into the managerial role and bring a fresh, invigorated mindset to the Bronx.
The Prospect of Derek Jeter’s Return
Bringing Derek Jeter back into the Yankees fold would send shockwaves of excitement throughout the fanbase and demonstrate that ownership is not content with a long-standing championship drought. Jeter’s return would generate even more fervor than simply reaching the World Series. Currently, the city is nursing the sting of both a World Series defeat and losing Juan Soto to their crosstown rivals. For some time now, fans have been vocal about their desire for Boone to step down, and a Jeter-led Yankees could be the rejuvenation they’re calling for.
Back in July 2017, Jeter entered the world of team management by purchasing a stake in the Miami Marlins, eventually becoming their CEO. Although he only held a 4% stake, controlling owner Bruce Sherman entrusted him with the franchise’s day-to-day operations. However, by late February, Jeter parted ways with the Marlins, freeing him from any commitments and opening up new possibilities in the baseball world.
Jeter’s passion for baseball remains as strong as ever, and his potential move to a managerial role with the Yankees could be a match made in heaven. Renowned for his discipline and deep understanding of the game, Jeter could bring those same qualities to managing, fostering an environment of excellence and strategic adeptness that few others can rival.
The Case for Moving on From Aaron Boone
Under standard MLB metrics, Aaron Boone has performed well for the Yankees. Though, if his tenure were to end this 2025 MLB season, his resume is enticing enough that other teams would quickly express interest. But for the Yankees, only one World Series appearance in seven seasons, without a victory, doesn’t cut it. Greater success, like consistent World Series or American League Championship Series appearances, may have changed perceptions.
Given the Yankees’ substantial payroll and influence, Boone needs to propel this team to peak performance as the season culminates, particularly in October. Other managers have succeeded with significantly smaller budgets, yet they’ve managed to reach or even win it all, highlighting the expectations Boone faces with the Yankees.
With 2025 ahead, the Yankees might consider keeping Boone on a tight leash, with Derek Jeter waiting in the wings. If the team falters or stagnates, swap Boone for Jeter could be an impactful move, potentially providing the fresh leadership needed to reinvigorate the Yankees and fully harness their potential.
