In a significant move for the Yankees, the team has decided to designate veteran DJ LeMahieu for assignment, a development that felt like an inevitable conclusion after Jazz Chisholm Jr. made the switch back to second base. With the Yankees on the hook for roughly $22 million through the end of next season, the decision reflects the reality of LeMahieu’s dwindling production and an increasing number of injuries that have hampered his play in recent years. His contributions on both offense and defense have diminished to the point where the Yankees found it necessary to make this tough call.
Interestingly, July has seen LeMahieu batting a respectable 7-for-15, which offers a glimpse of the talent he can still showcase. However, his overall season stats tell a different story, as he carries a line of .266/.338/.336 with just two home runs over 45 games. For a player of his caliber, that kind of production would typically be acceptable, especially if paired with elite defense. Unfortunately, LeMahieu’s arm strength has waned, restricting him to second base where his range isn’t what it used to be. The days of being a stolen-base threat are behind him as well.
As the Yankees approach the trade deadline, they were already in need of a third baseman, even before this roster shake-up. Oswald Peraza, a solid fielder who hasn’t quite hit his stride at the plate, is expected to take over the hot corner for now, with Jorbit Vivas and JC Escarra also in the mix. Given the current state of their pitching staff—injuries to ace Gerrit Cole, Fernando Cruz, Luis Gil, Clarke Schmidt, and others—New York’s shopping list looks extensive as they navigate this critical period.
Yankees GM Brian Cashman remarked on the team’s aspirations: “I’d certainly love to import a starter, some relievers, and an infielder as well, if possible. But that’s a long list. I’m not sure if this will be a deep deadline or not, so I don’t know how active we can be. But we will try to be active, I can tell you that, and we will try to import improvements. That’s the gig.” With the trade market starting to take shape as the amateur draft approaches, let’s take a closer look at five third basemen who could draw the Yankees’ interest this deadline.
Nolan Arenado (Cardinals)
One of the biggest names available, Arenado has been a target for the Yankees in the past, having reportedly been in talks with them last offseason. However, bringing him on board to replace LeMahieu would raise questions, as Arenado, now 34, is also experiencing a decline in performance, both offensively and defensively, even though he remains quite good in the field. With $40 million owed through 2027, this potential swap might not add up as cleanly as some would hope. Still, if the Yankees are looking for an upgrade over Peraza, Arenado could fit the bill, despite no longer being the top-tier player he once was.
Ke’Bryan Hayes (Pirates)
Hayes, the son of former Yankee Charlie Hayes, may pique the Yankees’ interest given his exceptional defensive skills—arguably the best in the game—despite his struggles with the bat. At 28 years old and signed through 2029 at a manageable $8 million per season, Hayes presents an intriguing option. If a team believes it can elevate his hitting, even with league-average production, he would be incredibly valuable thanks to his glove.
Ryan McMahon (Rockies)
McMahon, LeMahieu’s former teammate in Colorado, offers solid defensive capabilities. However, the Rockies operate unpredictably in the trade market, so it’s uncertain whether they would entertain offers for him. With a $16 million salary in 2026 and 2027, McMahon’s value is relatively high, though his offensive numbers have been bolstered by the favorable hitting conditions at Coors Field. The Yankees might consider reaching out, but McMahon’s availability is far from guaranteed.
Eugenio Suárez (Diamondbacks)
Now here’s a name that checks a lot of boxes for the Yankees. As a rental player who provides legitimate power in the middle of the order, Suárez could add the necessary punch behind Aaron Judge and the rest of the lineup. The Diamondbacks are currently in a tough spot, trailing in the wild-card race, which makes their decision to trade Suárez complicated. However, should he become available, he would represent the most significant upgrade at third base for New York, providing a strong addition as they navigate the rest of the season.
Ramón Urías (Orioles)
With the Orioles under interim management and looking to offload assets, Urías has emerged as a potential target. He boasts team control through 2026, is known for his solid defensive skills, and has the ability to hit left-handers effectively. While he may not be the flashiest choice for Yankees fans, Urías offers a clear upgrade over Peraza and is likely to be on the trading block.
As the trade deadline approaches, the Yankees face crucial decisions that could shape their roster and playoff aspirations for the remainder of the season. With several third-base options on the table, expect New York to stay active, looking to bolster their lineup and pitching staff amid their current challenges.
