Love him or hate him, ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit is arguably the biggest voice in all of college football.
His word and opinion carry weight. When he speaks, people listen … Which is why most people are curious what his stance is on the current landscape of college football.
It’s no secret the sport is facing a big challenge. While it’s more popular than it’s been in a long time, the new world of NIL and the transfer portal has thrown a wrench into the system.
NIL is a good thing.
The transfer portal is a good thing.
NIL + transfer portal combined = disaster for college football.
Here’s why ⬇️ pic.twitter.com/WqR3osvMTD
— Adam Breneman (@AdamBreneman81) February 26, 2024
Appearing on OutKick’s “Don’t @ Me with Dan Dakich,” Herbstreit spoke about the situation and offered some interesting suggestions.
“I feel like the NCAA has lost any power whatsoever in college football,” he said. “I feel like, at this point, as we go to this new world, I would not be surprised. I don’t know how they’d get there. You’d take the Big Ten, whoever it’s going to be – it’s like 60 teams, it’s the Big Ten, it’s the SEC, the ACC and the Big 12 and whoever else – I think they should go form their own world.”
NCAA NIL | Kirk Herbstreit lays out college football's path after NCAA loses NIL ruling: 'Losing power by the day' https://t.co/2imNjhRH4L
— Athletes Channel (@AthletesChannel) February 27, 2024
Herbstreit proposed the formation of a new governing body consisting of major conferences such as the Big Ten, SEC, ACC, and Big 12, effectively separating from the NCAA.
“Create their own governing body. Get one voice, one commissioner, instead of everyone having to get in agreement – these guys don’t always feel comfortable with each other – get one voice,” he said.
The NCAA is so worthless that they're choosing to fight candy and gatorade instead of worry about the fact the Big Ten and SEC is about to tell them to kick rocks. https://t.co/vD1H3YT9G7
— Kayce Smith (@KayceSmith) February 22, 2024
He emphasized the need for unity among conference commissioners and the necessity of partnership with players to address issues like NIL compensation and revenue sharing.
Additionally, Herbstreit highlighted the importance of accommodating both players and coaches in areas such as the transfer portal, which has become such an enormous issue.
“You got to talk about transfer portal, you got to make that more accommodating to the players and the coaches. Where you have more staying power for a program,” he said.
"Their needs to be some reins on this thing we call college football."
Pat Freiermuth and the guys dive into the pros and cons of NIL and how it could have a negative impact on the young players. 👇 pic.twitter.com/hMvCGBUOC5
— State Media (@StateMediaPSU) February 21, 2024
Regarding the potential transition, Herbstreit acknowledged challenges but stressed its inevitability.
“I would pull out away from the NCAA, create my own governing body, I would partner with the players. I think you’d have to go through things like NIL and make some realistic changes,” he said, adding that the new league would also have to address revenue sharing.”
At what point does the SEC/Big Ten coalition become the new defacto NCAA and we start this mess back at the beginning? https://t.co/Zamo6RDAWz
— Jacob Duncan 🎣 🦣 (@jacobtduncan) February 26, 2024
“I don’t know how you’d get there, but I think that’s where we’re headed,” he said. “Players are going to be employees; you’re late to a meeting, you’re fined. It’s basically going to be the NFL in college football.”
“Somehow, we still have to do academics, talk about the importance of getting an education, even though nobody wants to hear that, it is,” he added.
Kirk Herbstreit is only in the game to contact your top recruits’ family and influence his decision https://t.co/MOvNNcovzx
— vacca (@VaquitaDawg) February 22, 2024
“Yeah, I think the NCAA is losing power by the day, and I think eventually that’s what I see happening is they’re going to have to form their own world for college football,” he concluded.
Richard Sherman ARRESTED for DUI, Remains in CUSTODY + @RepPatFallon & @KirkHerbstreit join the show! https://t.co/aYbpefkRVT
— OutKick (@Outkick) February 26, 2024
Of course, Herbie isn’t the only person to suggest such changes.
What do you think of his ideas?
With no firm guardrails in place, it’s clear that if we continue down the current path we’re on, it’s going to get ugly.
What changes would you make to fix the system???