The NFLPA has released their highly-anticipated “report card” which showcases what players truly think of the organization they play for.
The survey includes the assessment of over 1,700 players across the league, which is a much stronger sample size than the inaugural report card last year.
“Over 1,700 of our players provided information to share with one another about their current club, not only to help them make important career decisions, but also help raise standards across the league,” stated the NFLPA in a press release.
“The standards we are seeking to elevate are ones that help support the players and their families as they come to work every day.”
President JC Tretter breaks down the goals of the NFLPA Player Team Report Cards in his latest column–see how the grades were weighted here: https://t.co/YckxqmU70L.#TeamReportCards pic.twitter.com/envF0keeRq
— NFLPA (@NFLPA) February 28, 2024
Among the notable findings, only three NFL head coaches received an A+ grade from the players: Andy Reid of the Kansas City Chiefs, Dan Campbell of the Detroit Lions, and Kevin O’Connell of the Minnesota Vikings.
Reid and Campbell’s inclusion comes as little surprise, given their outstanding reputations across the league, and certainly in their locker rooms.
Reid is one of the most respected and beloved coaches in NFL history. Fresh off winning back-to-back Super Bowls, you’d be hard-pressed to find many (if any) players who don’t speak extremely highly of him.
Meanwhile, Campbell may not have the success of Reid just yet, but he has completely changed the culture in Detroit – something that was once thought impossible.
The Dan Campbell playoff locker room speech is even better than you'd hope.
What a moment for the @Lions and Detroit. 💙pic.twitter.com/zSsCtqCXCK
— NFL (@NFL) January 15, 2024
The inclusion of O’Connell is an impressive feather in the cap for the young coach who often flies under the radar when many people think of the stronger coaches in the league.
Kevin O’Connell receives A+ grade from players survey.. O’Connell is a players coach & leads with a positive approach and that sometimes has worked & others it has limited his impact in some aspects of personnel decisions.. never been a candidate for NFL HC of the year #Skol pic.twitter.com/U9D9qFZUln
— Rick Sosa (@sosarick) February 28, 2024
On the other hand, two names probably immediately popped in your head when you think of who the worst graded coach in the league is.
Keep in mind, even fired coaches count … Therefore, it’s got to be down between (former) Las Vegas Raiders head coach Josh McDaniels and (former) Los Angeles Chargers head coach Brandon Staley.
Both were equally awful – but only one seemed to be universally despised by every player in the locker room…
That’s right, it’s none other than McDaniels who finished with a D grade.
Bruh they fucking hated Josh McDaniels LOL #Raiders pic.twitter.com/PwxWqt2ABv
— TD (@TDNZL) February 28, 2024
Having said that, it’s not unfair to say that McDaniels didn’t get the best of shakes in Vegas.
His old-school ways may have rubbed a lot of players the wrong way – but that’s not necessarily McDaniels’ fault.
Some coaches may be brilliant coordinators who just aren’t cut out to be HEAD coaches … We see it all the time.
That may very well be the case with McDaniels. He’s now failed twice in the league as a head coach. However, no one would ever question or doubt his impact as an offensive coordinator.
That’s a position he will most likely find himself back in sooner rather than later (perhaps with whatever team Bill Belichick ends up with).
Tom Brady vs Josh McDaniels this time pic.twitter.com/tT8IaDipiQ https://t.co/8albrQtwGJ
— TCL (@TitleTalkTCL) November 13, 2023
The biggest surprise to emerge from the report card was the fact that Kansas City Chiefs owner Clark Hunt was ranked as the WORST owner in all of football, finishing with an “F-” (!!!) grade.
Owning a team that’s won three Super Bowls in five years, including in back-to-back seasons, has to mean you’re doing SOMETHING right, doesn’t it?
Chiefs owner Clark Hunt was ranked dead last among the owners in the NFLPA survey 😬
Not the best results for the defending back-to-back Super Bowl champs. pic.twitter.com/QOMFxS47Pg
— Yahoo Sports (@YahooSports) February 28, 2024
The disgraceful ranking is apparently due to the fact that Chiefs players are unhappy with Hunt’s alleged reluctance to invest back into the team, particularly when it comes to their facilities.
“The number one complaint when it comes to the facilities is the locker room. Though the players received actual chairs with backs to sit in at their lockers in response to last year’s feedback, it did not change the fact that the locker room is overdue for a renovation,” the report stated.
“What adds to the frustration is that management told the players that renovations would come after the 2022 season. The players went on to win the Super Bowl and when they arrived back at their facility for the 2023-2024 season, they realized the team never followed through with the promised renovation (other than adding chairs).”
Despite riding high off of back to back Super Bowl titles and 3 in the last 5 seasons, Clark Hunt is having his worst offseason as the Chiefs owner. That's all due to the fact that he's now expected to do something that he has been notorious for not doing… and that's put money… pic.twitter.com/MCAG4T2gvd
— 🗣🎙‼️ (@LanceTHESPOKEN) February 29, 2024
But the criticism doesn’t stop there…
“The players feel that the training room is significantly understaffed, with only 43% of the team responding that they get an adequate amount of one-on-one treatment time,” the report read.
“Players feel that the staff is unwilling to provide the necessary treatment to support recovery and performance; for example, players are not allowed to get preventative treatment (soft tissue work, other care) for soreness and day-to-day issues, a regular offering across the NFL.”
“From the results, it is clear that there has not been a significant reinvestment back into the facilities even after consistent success,” the report added. “That has led to a high level of frustration among player respondents and reflects in club owner Clark Hunt’s ranking as the least willing to invest in team facilities among all NFL owners/ownership group in the opinions of the respondents.”
Now, it makes more sense!
Clark Hunt on the recent NFLPA Report which ranked the #Chiefs 31st and ranked Owner Clark Hunt as 32nd in the survey. “The practice facility is certainly a high priority for us.” pic.twitter.com/UOg6tzWURo
— Harold R. Kuntz (@HaroldRKuntz3) February 28, 2024
Here are all the details on the much-anticipated report card…
The Player Team Report Cards are back. Last year, the report cards led to players feeling more informed about their workplace & this year several new categories were added including Head Coach, Owner + Dietician/Nutritionist.
Take a look here: https://t.co/RV0ZNDNb2h. pic.twitter.com/vfEv6A7d2s— NFLPA (@NFLPA) February 28, 2024
What are your overall thoughts on the report card?
Where did your team rank?
Are you worried that less-than-stellar grades in certain areas will hurt your team’s ability to attract high-quality free agents???
"The Cowboys have lush facilities and they've been a soft franchise for 25 years."
— @ColinCowherd isn't bothered by Kansas City being ranked 31st on NFLPA report card pic.twitter.com/YruNQ001de
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) February 29, 2024