As the dust settles on the emergence of torpedo bats in the early days of the 2025 MLB season, the conversation around this innovative hitting tool continues to reverberate throughout baseball. After making a significant splash just a week ago, many players, coaches, and insiders share their reactions and insights, pondering the longevity and legitimacy of this trend.
The buzz began with the question of familiarity. Andrew Benintendi of the Chicago White Sox admitted he hadn’t heard of torpedo bats before, preferring to stick with his tried-and-true bat that has served him well for nearly a decade. It’s a sentiment echoed by many—a blend of curiosity and caution. Meanwhile, Robert Van Scoyoc, the hitting coach for the Dodgers, mentioned his awareness of bat fitting, but torpedo bats were a new concept to him, highlighting how quickly innovations can spread through the league.
Ryan O’Hearn of the Baltimore Orioles shed light on the driving force behind the trend: assistant GM Sig Mejdal, a former NASA engineer, who has been advocating for the use of torpedo bats. O’Hearn noted the bat’s unique feel, admitting that while it may take some adjustment, it has potential benefits based on player analytics. Dansby Swanson of the Cubs, too, remarked that while he finds the product fascinating, it’s still a stage of experimentation for many.
As mixed opinions came forward, players like Adam Ottavino and Nolan Schanuel shared their experiences. Ottavino observed that players have historically engaged in tinkering with bat designs, and while there’s buzz surrounding the Yankees’ early-season success with these bats, he emphasized that the innovation is widespread, not limited to just one team. Schanuel acknowledged a point of curiosity when he first encountered a torpedo bat in spring training, admitting that it felt unconventional at first but appreciated the scientific reasoning behind its design.
Turning to the practical aspect, Max Muncy reported a mixed experience, noting he felt slightly off-plane with the torpedo bat during a game. He opted to revert to his regular bat for more familiarity. Matt Shaw of the Cubs echoed similar sentiments, sharing that during batting practice, the heavier feel of the bat didn’t impress him, but he remained open to further exploration.
The baseball world is known for its cycles of skepticism and enthusiasm, and this trend is no different. Michael A. Taylor of the White Sox expressed interest in trying one, while Byron Buxton of the Twins confidently stated that he wouldn’t change his routine that’s already yielding results. O’Hearn delivered a frank assessment based on his limited use—one at-bat leading to a swift dismissal of the bat.
Despite the varying levels of enthusiasm and openness to experimentation, a consensus emerged about the overall excitement surrounding the innovation. Mark Canha of the Royals highlighted the importance of players finding every possible edge against the increasingly challenging pitchers of today’s game. Freddie Freeman added that if a bat works for someone and it’s within the rules, they should feel free to use it.
As the conversation shifted toward whether these bats might stick around, players reflected on past trends in bat design. Nicky Lopez noted the adjustment required when switching from familiar equipment, emphasizing that it takes time to hone in on a new sweet spot. Nico Hoerner mentioned that while he’s been utilizing the torpedo bats, he believes it’s more about adapting than conforming—a note that highlights the individuality of each player’s swing.
The overarching question of whether torpedo bats signify a fleeting trend or something more permanent remains to be seen. Many within the sport are intrigued, suggesting their potential to enhance offensive production, especially in a league that craves excitement and scoring. While debates simmer over their place in baseball, one thing is clear: torpedo bats are igniting discussions, signaling a lively start to the season as everyone keeps an eye on how this story unfolds.
