Navigating the Red Sox’s Third Base Dilemma: Devers vs. Bregman
As the Boston Red Sox navigate through Spring Training, they’re faced with a situation that’s created quite a buzz: the clash between Rafael Devers and Alex Bregman for the starting third base spot. The stakes couldn’t be higher, and the decision-making process is proving to be a challenging one for the organization.
This drama unfolded following Bregman’s recent signing of a lucrative three-year, $120 million contract. While initially hailed as a strategic move to fortify the lineup, it’s quickly become clear that the hot corner is now a site of contention. Fans and analysts alike are buzzing about how this position battle will unfold, given that both Bregman and Devers are elite talents with compelling cases for playing time.
The Case for Rafael Devers
Rafael Devers has been synonymous with the Red Sox since making his debut in 2017. He played a colossal role in the team’s 2018 World Series triumph, cementing his place as a cornerstone player with a career batting average of .279 and two Silver Slugger awards to his name. His prowess at the plate is well-documented, and his size—standing six feet tall and weighing 235 pounds—gives him the physicality that fans and coaches typically want in a third baseman.
Devers has made it abundantly clear he is committed to manning the hot corner. Recently, when asked about moving to a designated hitter role, he succinctly said, “No,” and reiterated, “I play third.” His conviction suggests the emotional weight of this decision goes beyond mere roster logistics; it’s about identity and role within the franchise.
While Devers has dabbled at second and shortstop in the past, it hasn’t been a successful experiment. His limited experience at those positions reinforces the idea that third base is where he belongs—an area where he can thrive defensively while bringing a powerful bat to the lineup.
The Argument for Alex Bregman
On the flip side, Alex Bregman brings a defensive acumen that is hard to ignore. Over his nine-year career, he has only made 93 errors, a tribute to his reliability at the position. Just last season, he earned the AL Gold Glove award at third base, showcasing his ability to make a difference with the glove.
Should Bregman start at third, it would, unfortunately, mean a shift for Devers, who would likely be relegated to a full-time DH role. While the DH position has a rich history within the Red Sox franchise—think of legends like David Ortiz—the move poses challenges both strategically and emotionally for Devers.
However, starting Bregman could open up intriguing lineup possibilities. With his versatility to play second base, the Red Sox have the opportunity to provide playing time for other emerging talents. For instance, Ceddanne Rafaela has shown promise and could slot in at second base, allowing Roman Anthony—ranked as a top prospect nationally—to make his mark soon after being called up.
What Lies Ahead
Red Sox manager Alex Cora has a balancing act on his hands, particularly as he navigates the differing visions from the previous regime and the current front office led by Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow. Cora’s comments suggest a fresh direction—one that might not hold traditional promises made to Devers when he signed his monumental 10-year, $313.5 million extension in 2023.
Ultimately, the Red Sox must weigh their options carefully. Whether they prioritize defensive prowess with Bregman or the longstanding relationship and bat of Devers, this decision will not only impact the immediate roster but also set the tone for the team’s future. While both players provide unique advantages, the rivalry for the starting third base position symbolizes broader themes within the franchise—identity, talent maximization, and the quest for continued championship success.
It’s going to be a fascinating spring, and no matter which direction the Red Sox choose to go, one thing is for sure: the tension at the hot corner is just getting started.
